Table of Contents
Usage-based car insurance is a type of auto insurance where your premium is calculated based on how you actually drive rather than on demographic proxies like age, ZIP code, or credit score. Instead of pricing you the same as every other driver in your statistical category, a usage-based program tracks real data about your driving behavior, including how much you drive, how fast you brake, when you drive, and how smoothly you handle the vehicle, and adjusts your rate accordingly. Safe, low-mileage drivers can see meaningful discounts. Aggressive or high-mileage drivers may see less benefit or, in some programs, higher rates.
For the right driver, usage-based insurance can be one of the most effective ways to lower a car insurance premium. Understanding how it works, which programs are worth enrolling in, and when it makes sense for your situation is the starting point.
How Usage-Based Car Insurance Works
The Telematics Device or App
Usage-based insurance programs collect driving data through one of two methods: a physical plug-in device that connects to your vehicle’s OBD-II port, or a smartphone app that uses your phone’s GPS and sensors. Both methods track similar data points, though app-based programs have become more common as they eliminate the need to mail a device and are easier to set up.
The OBD-II port is a standard diagnostic port found on nearly all vehicles manufactured after 1996 and is typically located under the dashboard on the driver’s side. Plug-in dongles from programs like Progressive Snapshot connect to this port and begin transmitting driving data immediately. App-based programs from insurers like State Farm Drive Safe and Save or Allstate Drivewise are downloaded to your phone and run in the background during trips.
What Data Gets Tracked
The specific data points collected vary by program, but most usage-based insurance systems monitor some combination of the following:
• Miles driven: total distance covered per day, week, and month.
• Braking behavior: how often and how hard you brake, with hard braking events flagged as negative factors.
• Acceleration: rapid acceleration from stops, which correlates with aggressive driving patterns.
• Speed: time spent driving above posted speed limits or above a threshold speed.
• Time of day: driving between midnight and 4 AM is flagged by many programs as higher-risk and weighted negatively.
• Phone use: some app-based programs detect phone handling while driving, including texting or holding the phone.
• Cornering: sharp turns or lane changes that suggest erratic driving.
Not every program tracks all of these factors, and the weighting of each factor varies significantly between insurers. Some programs focus primarily on mileage. Others weight braking and time-of-day most heavily. Understanding which factors your chosen program emphasizes helps you focus on the behaviors that affect your score most.
How Your Rate Is Calculated
Programs typically run for an initial monitoring period, often 30 to 90 days, at the end of which a discount or adjusted rate is applied based on your driving score. Some programs apply a guaranteed initial discount just for enrolling, then adjust further based on actual behavior. Others wait for the monitoring period to conclude before applying any discount.
The discount is then applied to your policy premium at renewal. Most programs that use the data positively produce discounts in the range of 5 to 40 percent. Programs that can also increase rates, which is not universal but applies to some insurers, will raise your premium if your driving score falls below a certain threshold. Before enrolling, confirm whether the program can raise your rate or only reduce it.
Check this out: Save up to 40% on car insurance
Types of Usage-Based Insurance Programs
Pay-As-You-Drive (PAYD)
Pay-as-you-drive programs price insurance primarily based on mileage. The less you drive, the less you pay. This model is most beneficial for people who work from home, use public transit for most of their commute, or drive significantly fewer miles annually than the average driver. Metromile was among the most well-known pure PAYD programs, though it was acquired by Lemonade. Several major insurers now offer mileage-weighted pricing within their broader UBI programs.
Pay-How-You-Drive (PHYD)
Pay-how-you-drive programs price insurance based on driving behavior rather than purely on distance. Braking patterns, speed, cornering, acceleration, and time-of-day all factor into your score. This model rewards careful drivers regardless of how much they drive. A commuter who drives 20,000 miles per year but drives smoothly and safely may save more under a PHYD program than a low-mileage driver who has a heavy foot.
Hybrid Programs
Most major insurer programs today combine elements of both mileage tracking and behavior scoring. The resulting rate considers both how much you drive and how you drive. These hybrid programs are now the most common form of usage-based insurance in the US market and are offered by nearly every major carrier.
Major Usage-Based Insurance Programs in the US
Progressive Snapshot
Progressive Snapshot is one of the original and most widely known usage-based programs. It uses either a plug-in device or a smartphone app to track braking, speed, and time of day. Snapshot advertises discounts of up to 30 percent for safe drivers. The program can affect rates in both directions: very safe drivers earn significant discounts, while drivers with frequent hard braking or late-night driving may see smaller discounts or no discount at the end of the monitoring period. Progressive is transparent about this and is upfront that rates could be higher for some drivers.
State Farm Drive Safe and Save
Drive Safe and Save operates through the State Farm app and tracks mileage, braking, acceleration, and phone use. Enrolled customers receive an initial discount of up to 10 percent for turning on the program, with total potential savings of up to 30 percent for safe driving behavior. The program does not increase rates based on poor scores, which makes it a lower-risk option for drivers who are uncertain how their habits will score.
Allstate Drivewise
Allstate Drivewise runs through the Allstate mobile app and tracks speed, braking, and time of day. Drivewise rewards safe driving with cash back deposits into a rewards account rather than direct premium discounts. The program does not increase rates for poor scores, and participants receive a reward every six months based on their driving data. The model is slightly different from standard premium discount programs and may appeal to drivers who prefer tangible rewards over a percentage discount on an abstract premium figure.
GEICO DriveEasy
GEICO DriveEasy uses a smartphone app to monitor phone use, braking, cornering, and time of day. The program provides a scorecard that breaks down each factor, allowing drivers to see exactly what is affecting their score. Discounts of up to 25 percent are advertised for safe drivers. GEICO is clear that DriveEasy is available in most but not all states.
Nationwide SmartRide and Liberty Mutual RightTrack
Nationwide SmartRide and Liberty Mutual RightTrack are additional programs worth knowing. SmartRide uses a plug-in device and tracks braking, acceleration, idle time, and mileage. RightTrack runs through an app or device for a 90-day initial period and then sets a discount that applies for the policy lifetime. RightTrack advertises discounts of 5 to 30 percent and, like Drivewise, does not increase rates for poor scores during the monitoring period.
Who Benefits Most from Usage-Based Car Insurance?
Low-Mileage Drivers
If you drive significantly fewer miles per year than the average American driver, which the Federal Highway Administration estimates at around 13,500 miles annually, usage-based insurance is almost always worth investigating. Insurers price standard policies partly based on assumed mileage risk. If your actual mileage is 5,000 to 8,000 miles per year, a mileage-weighted UBI program can meaningfully reduce your premium to reflect your actual exposure.
Remote workers, retirees, urban residents who use transit for most trips, and people who work close to home are the natural beneficiaries of mileage-based programs. If you have been paying a standard rate based on average mileage assumptions while actually driving far less, the adjustment from a UBI program can be one of the largest single savings available on your policy.
Safe and Consistent Drivers
Drivers who consistently brake smoothly, avoid hard acceleration, stay off the road in the early morning hours, and keep their speed within reasonable limits are the ideal customers for behavior-based UBI programs. These programs are designed to surface the premium savings that standard pricing models cannot offer because they are based on population averages rather than individual behavior.
Young Drivers with Good Habits
Young drivers typically face the highest standard car insurance premiums because age is a primary risk factor in actuarial pricing. A 22-year-old with genuinely safe driving habits pays the same base rate as a 22-year-old with a history of hard braking and late-night driving under standard pricing. A behavior-based UBI program is one of the few mechanisms available to a young safe driver to demonstrate their actual risk level and earn a rate that reflects it.
Who Should Think Carefully Before Enrolling
High-Mileage Drivers
If you drive 20,000 or more miles per year, mileage-weighted UBI programs may offer limited benefit even if your behavior scores well. Some programs will produce a smaller discount for high-mileage drivers regardless of how safely they drive because total exposure correlates with total risk. If your annual mileage is substantially above average, compare the UBI program’s maximum savings potential against a standard policy comparison before assuming UBI is the better route.
Drivers with Demanding Schedules
Drivers who routinely commute during the early morning hours, work night shifts, or drive frequently between midnight and 4 AM will be penalized by most time-of-day weighting in UBI programs regardless of how safely they drive during those hours. If your work schedule is non-negotiable and falls in the higher-risk windows that UBI programs flag, the time-of-day factor may offset the savings you would earn from safe behavior during other hours.
Privacy-Conscious Drivers
Usage-based insurance programs collect detailed location and behavioral data through your vehicle or smartphone. Depending on the program, this data may be shared with third parties or accessed in the context of a claim. Some drivers are uncomfortable with continuous tracking and the data implications, regardless of the potential premium savings. Reading the privacy policy of any UBI program before enrolling is advisable if this is a concern for your household.
How to Compare Usage-Based Insurance Rates
Understanding usage-based insurance is only the first step. The question that actually matters for your wallet is whether a UBI program at the insurer you currently use, or a new insurer you compare against, will produce a better rate than what you are paying now.
The most common mistake drivers make is assuming their current insurer’s UBI program is the best available option simply because it is what they already have access to. Rates for the same driver profile vary significantly across insurers, and the interaction between your specific driving habits and each insurer’s scoring model creates further variation. A driver whose behavior scores well under Progressive Snapshot may find that a different insurer’s standard rate is more competitive than the Snapshot discount, or vice versa.
Beem’s car insurance comparison tool lets you compare personalized quotes from multiple top providers in about five minutes, side by side, without filling out a separate form for each insurer. Whether you are evaluating a UBI program at your current carrier, switching to a new insurer for a better base rate, or simply checking whether your current premium still reflects your actual risk profile, comparing in one place gives you the full picture. Drivers who compare rather than renew on autopilot save up to 40 percent on their premium.
Tips to Score Well on a Usage-Based Insurance Program
Brake early and gradually: Hard braking is the single most heavily weighted negative factor in most UBI programs. Leaving more following distance and anticipating stops earlier produces a smoother braking profile and a better score.
Avoid driving between midnight and 4 AM when possible: Late-night driving carries the highest risk weighting in most programs. Shifting trips that are flexible to daytime hours removes this penalty from your score without requiring any change to your actual driving behavior.
Put your phone away before starting the engine: App-based programs that detect phone handling during driving count this as a significant negative factor. Placing the phone in a mount, activating Do Not Disturb while driving, or simply putting it in the back seat eliminates this data point from your score.
Batch errands to reduce total trips: Mileage-weighted programs score fewer total miles positively. Combining multiple errands into a single trip reduces your mileage total and improves your score on programs that weight distance heavily.
Check your score regularly during the monitoring period: Most programs provide real-time feedback through their app or portal. Reviewing your score weekly during the monitoring period lets you identify which behaviors are affecting your rating and adjust before the final score is set.
Check out Beem for on-point financial insights and recommendations to spend, save, plan and protect your money like an expert. Download the Beem app today!
Frequently Asked Questions
Does usage-based insurance raise your rates?
It depends on the program. Some programs, including Progressive Snapshot, can raise your rate if your driving score falls below a threshold. Others, including State Farm Drive Safe and Save, Allstate Drivewise, and Liberty Mutual RightTrack, only apply discounts and do not increase rates for poor scores during the monitoring period. Always confirm whether the specific program you are enrolling in can result in a rate increase before you participate. If you are concerned about your driving habits or your score, choosing a program that cannot raise your rate is the lower-risk option.
What data does usage-based insurance collect?
Most programs collect some combination of miles driven, braking patterns, acceleration behavior, speed, time of day, and in app-based programs, phone handling during driving. GPS location data may also be collected by some programs to verify routes and distances. The specific data points and how long they are retained vary by insurer. Review the privacy policy of any program before enrolling, and most major insurers publish a clear summary of what data is collected and how it is used.
Is usage-based car insurance worth it?
For low-mileage and safe drivers, usage-based insurance is frequently the most direct way to lower a car insurance premium. Drivers who cover fewer than 10,000 miles annually or who consistently exhibit smooth, careful driving habits are well-positioned to earn discounts that standard pricing models would not offer. For high-mileage drivers, those with demanding night schedules, or those who are not confident in their driving data, a standard policy comparison may produce a better result than a UBI program.
Does usage-based insurance require a device?
Not necessarily. Most major UBI programs offer a smartphone app as an alternative to a physical OBD-II plug-in device. The app uses your phone’s GPS and motion sensors to collect the same data points that a physical device would capture. Some programs allow you to choose between the device and the app based on your preference. App-based programs are increasingly the default option as they are easier to set up and do not require the insurer to mail a physical device to your address.
How much can you save with usage-based car insurance?
Advertised discounts vary by program but most programs quote a range of 5 to 30 percent for safe drivers, with some programs advertising up to 40 percent for the most consistently safe driving profiles. Initial enrollment discounts for simply signing up range from 5 to 10 percent at several major programs before driving data is even collected. The actual discount you receive depends on your driving behavior during the monitoring period and how your score compares to the program’s discount thresholds.
