Set-It-and-Forget-It: When Auto-Enrollment Fails You in 401(k) Plans

Auto-enrollment has revolutionized how Americans save for retirement. Automatically signing up new employees for their company’s 401(k) plan removes barriers and nudges people to start saving from day one. It’s a powerful tool for overcoming inertia and ensuring more workers have at least some money for their future.

But there’s a catch. While auto-enrollment gets you in the game, it can also lull you into a false sense of security. Many people assume that being auto-enrolled means their retirement is on track. A “set-it-and-forget-it” mindset can leave you with too little saved, the wrong investments, or missed growth opportunities. To build a secure retirement, you need to go beyond the default and take an active role in your 401(k) planning. What to do when auto-enrollment fails you in 401(k) plans? Read on to know more.

When Auto-Enrollment Fails You in 401(k) Plans

When auto-enrollment fails you in 401(k) plans, it usually means that the default system set up to help you start saving for retirement either didn’t function as expected or didn’t serve your personal financial needs. Let’s understand how auto-enrollment works in 401(k) plans and how you can take control of your retirement planning.

How Auto-Enrollment Works in 401(k) Plans

The Basics of Auto-Enrollment

Auto-enrollment means you’re automatically signed up for your employer’s 401(k) plan, usually at a default contribution rate, often 3% of your salary. Unless you opt out or make changes, a portion of your paycheck is invested in a default fund, typically a target-date fund chosen by your employer or plan provider.

This system is designed to make saving easy. You don’t have to fill out paperwork or make tough decisions right away. The money is deducted before you ever see it, helping you save without thinking about it.

The Behavioral Science Behind Auto-Enrollment

Why does auto-enrollment work so well? It leverages behavioral science, specifically our tendency toward inertia and decision paralysis. Many people do nothing when faced with a complex choice — how much to save, where to invest, what funds to pick. Auto-enrollment solves this by making saving the default, not the exception.

But the same psychology that gets you started can also keep you stuck. Most people never change their contribution rate or investment mix after being auto-enrolled. The default becomes the permanent setting, even if it’s not the best choice for your goals.

When Auto-Enrollment Fails to Deliver

Low Default Contribution Rates

Most auto-enrollment plans start you at a low contribution rate, often just 3% of your salary. While this is better than nothing, it’s far below the 10–15% many experts recommend for a comfortable retirement. If you never increase your contribution, you could fall far short.

Inappropriate Default Investments

Default investments, like target-date funds, are designed to be a “one-size-fits-most” solution. But they may not match your risk tolerance, financial situation, or retirement timeline. Some people end up too conservative, missing out on growth, while others are too aggressive, risking big losses close to retirement.

Lack of Engagement and Awareness

Auto-enrollment can breed complacency. Many employees don’t know their contribution rate, what they’re invested in, or whether they’re getting the full employer match. Annual plan updates and communications go unread, and opportunities for improvement are missed.

Real-World Consequences of “Set-It-and-Forget-It”

Falling Short of Retirement Goals

Your savings may stagnate if you stick with a low default contribution rate. Over the decades, the difference between saving 3% and 10% of your salary is massive. Missing out on employer matches or failing to increase contributions as your income grows can mean the difference between a comfortable retirement and having to work longer or scale back your lifestyle.

Mismatched Risk and Missed Growth

Default investments aren’t tailored to your unique needs. If you’re too conservative in your 20s and 30s, you might miss out on decades of growth. If you’re too aggressive in your 50s and 60s, you could face big losses just when you need stability. Not reviewing your investment mix can expose you to unnecessary risk or missed returns.

Overlooking Plan Fees and Features

Some default funds carry higher fees than other options in your plan. Over time, even small differences in fees can eat away at your returns. Many people also miss out on valuable features like Roth contributions, catch-up contributions (if you’re 50+), or automatic escalation that can help boost savings.

How to Take Control of Your 401(k) Beyond Auto-Enrollment

Review and Adjust Your Contribution Rate

Don’t settle for the default. Review your contribution rate and aim to increase it over time, especially when you get a raise or bonus. Many plans let you set up automatic escalation, so your savings rate goes up by 1% each year without you having to think about it.

Revisit Your Investment Choices

Assess your risk tolerance, time horizon, and retirement goals. Are you comfortable with your current investment mix? Explore options beyond the default fund, such as index funds, balanced funds, or a custom portfolio that better fits your needs.

Take Advantage of Plan Features

Learn about your plan’s features. Are you getting the full employer match? Can you make Roth contributions for tax-free growth? Are you eligible for catch-up contributions if you’re over 50? Take time to read the plan communications and ask questions if you’re unsure.

Schedule Annual 401(k) Check-Ups

Make it a habit to review your 401(k) at least once a year — ideally during open enrollment or after a raise. Set reminders to check your contribution rate, investment mix, and plan updates. Digital tools can help you track your progress and set new goals.

How Beem Can Help You Stay Proactive With Your 401(k)

Beem is a smart wallet app designed to help you stay engaged with your finances. With Beem, you can:

• Monitor Contributions and Investments: Track your 401(k) savings rate and investment performance in one place.
• Set Reminders for Reviews and Increases: Get notifications to review your plan, boost your contributions, or explore new investment options.
• Gain Insights for Optimization: Receive personalized suggestions to help you make the most of your 401(k), from maximizing employer matches to minimizing fees.

Beem makes it easier to move beyond “set-it-and-forget-it” and take an active role in your retirement planning.

Conclusion

Auto-enrollment is a helpful nudge, but it’s only the beginning of your retirement journey. Relying solely on “set-it-and-forget-it” can leave you underprepared, mismatched, or missing out on valuable opportunities. 

Take charge by reviewing your contribution rate, investment choices, and plan features at least once a year. With careful planning and the help of digital tools like Beem, you can take control of your retirement savings and build a more secure financial future. In addition, Beem’s Everdraft™ lets you withdraw up to $1,000 instantly and with no checks. Download the app here.

FAQs for When Auto-Enrollment Fails You in 401(k) Plans