Best Car Insurance In Fayetteville, NC

It is crucial to research, compare, and choose a provider that meets the legal requirements and provides the coverage and service you can rely on when looking for the best car insurance in Fayetteville, NC.
car insurance in Fayetteville
Best Car Insurance In Fayetteville, NC
Age, location, credit score, and driving history are considered when determining insurance premiums. Let’s explore options for the best car insurance in Fayetteville, NC.
In this article

Finding the best car insurance in Fayetteville, NC, is crucial, especially with the city’s bustling streets and the Fayetteville police reports responding to approximately 13,000 auto accidents each year. The challenge is met head-on by the local authorities, but for drivers, securing reliable and affordable car insurance is equally essential.

With the city’s unique characteristics impactNCing rates, Fayetteville’s auto insurance rates are 30% higher than other areas in North Carolina, aligning closely with the national average. Despite these challenges, reasonably-priced car insurance options exist, providing a silver lining for residents navigating the city’s busy roads. So, let’s explore the local dynamics and available insurance choices that are key in ensuring protection and affordability for Fayetteville drivers.

Overview Of Car Insurance In Fayetteville, NC

In Fayetteville, NC, car insurance rates may be higher than in other parts of North Carolina, but they align with the national average. Full-coverage insurance typically costs around $156 per month or $1,876 per year, approximately 7% lower than the national average. Fayetteville residents pay an average of $52 per month or $627 annually for minimum coverage. Among the insurance providers, Erie Insurance stands out as the most affordable option for liability coverage at $33 per month or $399 annually, followed by Nationwide at $38 per month or $462 annually.

Age, location, credit score, and driving history are considered when determining insurance premiums. Fayetteville drivers should know these factors can significantly influence their final premium costs. By understanding these dynamics and comparing quotes from different insurers, individuals can find the most suitable and affordable car insurance coverage in Fayetteville, NC.

Top 5 Car Insurance In Fayetteville, NC

Securing the right car insurance is like having a safety net for your vehicle on the roads of Fayetteville, NC. With various options available, finding a provider that offers reliable coverage, excellent customer service, and competitive rates is crucial. Here’s a breakdown of the top 5 car insurance options in Fayetteville, NC.

  • Beem
  • Hurley Insurance Group
  • Liberty Mutual
  • Erie
  • State Farm


For a top-notch guide to car insurance in Fayetteville, NC, Beem is the go-to choice. Simplifying the insurance process, Beem allows you to secure affordable coverage in just 5 minutes. With personalized quotes from major providers, you could save hundreds annually. The key factors influencing rates include your vehicle’s make, driving history, age, and credit score. Car insurance is not just a choice; it must cover liability and meet legal requirements.

Comparing car insurance quotes with Beem ensures an informed decision aligned with your budget. Choosing Beem’s auto insurance suggestions covers all vehicle damage, property damage, and personal injuries, providing complete protection. Use Beem’s user-friendly online tool to effectively compare rates, explore policy options, assess deductibles, and review premiums from different companies. Remember, auto insurance is mandated in most states. Beem streamlines the process, making it convenient and efficient to choose the right coverage for your needs and budget.

Hurley Insurance Group

For top-tier car insurance in Fayetteville, NC, the Hurley Insurance Group is a standout choice. With a commitment to serving the community since 1986, this local agency provides personalized service and a range of coverage options.

Hurley Insurance Group understands the unique needs of Fayetteville drivers, offering customized solutions tailored to individual requirements. They are dedicated to ensuring clients receive the right coverage at competitive rates.

Whether you’re seeking basic liability coverage or comprehensive protection, Hurley Insurance Group is known for its reliability and customer-centric approach. Choosing a local agency like Hurley ensures you get the attention and coverage that suits Fayetteville’s driving environment.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual is a top choice for reliable car insurance in Fayetteville, NC. With a history dating back to 1912, Liberty Mutual is one of America’s oldest insurance companies, offering coverage for cars, homes, power sports vehicles, and businesses. Purchasing customized car insurance online with Liberty Mutual could save you up to 12%, with an average annual rate of $1,752.

Liberty Mutual discounts safe drivers with a violation-free driving history, emphasizing that good drivers are made, not born. Insure multiple vehicles with Liberty Mutual to enjoy a multi-car discount, and further savings can be achieved by bundling auto and home insurance.


Our research shows that Erie is the go-to choice for affordable car insurance in Fayetteville, NC. With competitive rates, excellent customer satisfaction, and an above-average claims management score, Erie provides a winning combination for drivers.

Erie’s additional coverage, such as locked vehicle coverage and personal property insurance, makes it unique. Locked vehicle coverage ensures you’re covered for up to $75 if you accidentally lock your keys in your car. Moreover, personal property insurance under Erie protects against loss of clothing, luggage, and belongings in an insured car, offering coverage of up to $350 for physical damage.

Erie goes the extra mile by providing discounts for setting up automatic payments and installing safety devices like anti-lock brakes and homing devices. With an average rate of $872 for full coverage, Erie is the most affordable option in Fayetteville, making it a top choice for budget-conscious drivers.

State Farm

State Farm is a reliable choice for top-notch car insurance in Fayetteville, NC. Holding a substantial 16% of the auto insurance market share nationwide, it is recognized as the largest auto insurance company in the country. State Farm offers an average full coverage premium of $13 per month or $1240 per year, making it a competitive option for drivers.

With 158 offices across North Carolina, State Farm boasts an extensive network that includes exclusive local agents for personalized service. Whether you prefer face-to-face interactions or digital convenience, State Farm provides highly-rated mobile tools for easy policy management, claims filing, payments, and roadside assistance.

While State Farm’s competitive rates, especially for minimum coverage, appeal to budget-conscious individuals, it’s essential to consider its higher-than-average overall complaint index score from the National Association of Insurance Commissions (NAIC). Despite not offering accident forgiveness as an endorsement, State Farm’s combination of local presence and digital accessibility makes it a strong contender for comprehensive and convenient car insurance in Fayetteville, NC.

Car Insurance Requirements In Fayetteville, NC

In Fayetteville, NC, all drivers must carry, at the very least, the minimum coverage mandated by the state. However, most drivers find it prudent to opt for higher coverage amounts for comprehensive protection. The state’s minimum requirements, as mandated by law, are as follows:

  • $60,000 bodily injury liability per accident
  • $30,000 bodily injury liability per person
  • $25,000 property damage liability per accident
  • $60,000 underinsured/uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage per accident
  • $30,000 underinsured/uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage per person
  • $25,000 underinsured/uninsured motorist property damage coverage per accident

Fayetteville, NC, operates as an at-fault state in car accidents. In practical terms, this means that the driver deemed responsible for an accident must cover the costs of any resulting damage or injuries to the other involved parties. This is where liability coverage comes into play. Setting liability coverage limits well above the state-mandated minimums is advisable to ensure robust protection.

Types Of Car Insurance Coverage In Fayetteville, NC

Driving in Fayetteville, NC, means more than moving forward — staying protected on the roads. Fayetteville, NC’s insurance is here to ensure you stay mobile and secure. Let’s break down the various types of car insurance coverage, making it easy to choose the right protection for your vehicle and budget.

Liability Coverage

Liability insurance is fundamental in Fayetteville, encompassing bodily injury liability and property damage liability. The former covers medical expenses and lost wages for others in an at-fault accident. At the same time, the latter helps with repair costs for damage to another person’s property that you’re responsible for.

Collision Coverage

With Fayetteville’s bustling streets, collision coverage is crucial. It assists with repair or replacement costs for your vehicle after a collision, irrespective of fault. This coverage provides peace of mind, ensuring your car can be restored after an accident.

Comprehensive Coverage

Fayetteville’s diverse weather and urban environment pose various risks. Comprehensive coverage protects against theft, vandalism, fire, natural disasters, and non-collision incidents. Given the potential for theft and extreme weather, comprehensive coverage is a wise investment.

Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage

Despite state insurance laws, some drivers in Fayetteville may need more adequate coverage. Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage steps in to cover medical expenses and property damage if you’re in an accident with an inadequately insured driver

Medical Payments Coverage

This covers medical costs for you and your passengers after a covered car accident. It’s a crucial component to ensure everyone’s well-being.

Gap Coverage

If your car is totaled after an accident or stolen, this coverage helps pay the difference between the value of your vehicle and the amount you owe on the lease or loan.

Towing and Labor Coverage

Provides reimbursement for a tow and the labor costs associated with repairing your vehicle.

Rental Reimbursement Coverage

This helps with the cost of a rental car if your vehicle has to stay in the shop for an extended time after a covered accident.

Car Insurance In Fayetteville

Factors Influencing Car Insurance Rates In Fayetteville, NC

Car insurance rates can seem mysterious, but several factors influence your final premium. In Fayetteville, NC, knowing these factors can help you make informed decisions and save on your auto insurance. Let’s explore the key elements that insurers consider when determining car insurance rates.

State Requirements

Your car insurance policy must meet the minimum coverage requirements set by the state of North Carolina. This ensures all drivers are adequately insured and meet mandatory standards.


Age is a significant determinant of insurance rates. Younger drivers under 25 typically face higher premiums due to limited experience and higher accident risks. However, rates often decrease after turning 25.

Car Make and Model

The type of car you drive directly impacts insurance rates. Safer vehicles are generally cheaper to insure, while high-performance models can incur higher costs.

Driving Record

Your driving history is crucial. Accidents or traffic violations signal higher risk to insurers, resulting in higher premiums. A clean record usually means lower rates.

Yearly Mileage

Annual mileage influences rates. Long commutes may lead to higher premiums, while less time on the road can mean lower risk and lower premiums.

Credit History

Credit score affects rates. Good credit reflects responsibility and lower risk, leading to lower premiums compared to poor credit.

Zip Code

Your location impacts rates based on the likelihood of damage in your area. Some areas may qualify for discounts, while others may face rate increases.

Marital Status

Married individuals often enjoy lower rates due to statistical evidence of responsible behavior.


Gender can affect rates, with some demographics paying slightly less based on statistical risk assessments.

Finding The Right Car Insurance Provider In Fayetteville, NC

Securing the right car insurance provider in Fayetteville, NC, is vital in ensuring you have the coverage you need without stretching your budget. With numerous options available, it’s essential to consider factors such as coverage types, rates, customer service, and local intricacies specific to Fayetteville.

Follow these steps to find the optimal car insurance in Fayetteville:

Start by evaluating your unique needs, considering the state’s coverage requirements and additional options that suit your circumstances. Given Fayetteville’s specific driving conditions, understanding the type of coverage essential for comprehensive protection is crucial.

Conduct thorough research on reputable insurance providers operating in Fayetteville. Explore offerings from well-established companies like State Farm, Allstate, Progressive, and local agencies that may provide personalized service attuned to the city’s dynamics.

Compare quotes from various providers to strike the right balance between coverage and cost. Leverage online tools and engage with local agents to make well-informed decisions tailored to your specific needs and the driving environment in Fayetteville, NC.

Researching Local Insurance Companies

From affordable rates to reliable coverage, finding a company that aligns with your needs is essential. Let’s look at some prominent local insurance companies and their offerings.

One notable option is Erie Insurance, a Fayetteville-based company that prides itself on personalized service. Erie Insurance goes beyond the policies, taking the time to forge connections with clients and tailoring coverage to individual needs. Their community-centric approach creates a sense of trust, making them a go-to choice for many Fayetteville residents.

For those seeking comprehensive insurance experience, State Farm Insurance Agency emerges as a strong contender. They position themselves as a one-stop solution with offerings ranging from auto to specialized coverage. The knowledgeable agents at State Farm Insurance Agency guide clients through the intricacies of policies, providing clarity and assurance.

Comparing Coverage

Grasping the intricacies of coverage options is crucial to guaranteeing the appropriate protection while driving. In Cleveland, the average expense of auto insurance fluctuates depending on the specific type of coverage you opt for.

Minimum Coverage Rates

In Fayetteville, N.C., the average cost of minimum-coverage insurance is $52 per month or $627 per year. Surprisingly, this aligns with the national average of $52 per month or $625 per year, reflecting a competitive market for basic insurance needs.

Full Coverage Rates

Full-coverage car insurance, encompassing liability, comprehensive, and collision protection, averages $156 monthly or $1,876 yearly. Fayetteville offers a 7% savings compared to the national average. Erie Insurance is the most economical choice at $101 per month or $1,217 annually. This comprehensive option shields against various scenarios, ensuring your vehicle stays protected on Fayetteville’s roads without compromising your budget.

Here are some insurers to consider in Fayetteville, NC:

Car Insurance CompanyMonthly Average of Full Coverage RateMonthly Average of Min. coverage Rate
Erie Insurance$101$33
State Farm$130$46
North Carolina Farm Bureau$128$42
National General$171$57
Table 1.0. Comparing Coverage of Full and Minimum Coverage Rate

Filing A Car Insurance Claim In Fayetteville, NC

Filing a car insurance claim in North Carolina is crucial after an auto accident Especially in Fayetteville. Car accidents can be overwhelming, but your insurer can help you navigate the process and secure compensation for repairs, injuries, and other expenses.

After a car accident, follow the North Carolina Department of Insurance’s car accident checklist for Fayetteville drivers. Move your vehicle to a safe location and contact the Fayetteville Police, especially for reportable accidents involving death, injury, or property damage over $1,000.

North Carolina operates as an at-fault state for car accidents. It’s essential to be cautious when speaking with insurance adjusters to avoid misunderstandings that could impact your claim. Consulting with an experienced Fayetteville insurance attorney can be beneficial.

Your auto insurance company will assign a claims adjuster to your case. The adjuster investigates the claim and represents you in negotiations with all involved parties. They facilitate compensation for repairs, injuries, or other damages.

Your claims adjuster assists with repair claims, personal injury claims, and handling situations involving uninsured motorists. They may recommend repair facilities and arrange rental vehicles if needed. Your adjuster is your primary point of contact throughout the claim process in Fayetteville, ensuring you stay informed about its status.

Tips For Lowering Car Insurance Costs In Fayetteville, NC

Lowering car insurance costs in NC is a goal for many residents seeking to optimize their coverage while managing expenses. Here are actionable tips presented in points:

Compare Insurance Rates

Compare quotes from insurance companies in Fayetteville. Look for providers offering competitive rates and consider bundling policies for additional savings.

Maintain a Good Driving Record

Avoid accidents and traffic violations to ensure you have a clean driving record. Safe driving habits can qualify you for discounts with insurance companies.

Choose Higher Deductibles

Opt for higher deductibles on your car insurance policy. While this means paying more out of pocket in the event of a claim, it can significantly lower your monthly premiums.

Drive Less

Reducing your annual mileage can lower your costs, too. Consider carpooling, using public transportation, or working from home to decrease your time on the road.

Look for Discounts

Inquire about available discounts, such as those for good students, safe drivers, or vehicle safety features. These discounts can help lower your insurance expenses in Fayetteville, NC.


Finding the right car insurance in Fayetteville involves considering the numbers and understanding the local landscape. Research, compare, and choose a provider that meets the legal requirements and provides the coverage and service you can rely on. While having basic insurance is vital, additional coverage options for medical bills, rental cars, and towing can provide extra peace of mind. In Fayetteville, having car insurance is a rule to ensure the safety of everyone on the road.

The fundamental type of insurance, known as liability insurance, helps cover injuries to others and damage to their property. Recognized companies in Fayetteville offering these coverages include Beem, Hurley Insurance Group, Liberty Mutual, and Erie. Exploring different options, consulting with local agents, and comparing prices can help you find the best balance for your needs and budget. Utilizing tools like Beem to gather quotes ensures you make informed decisions for your auto insurance in Fayetteville, NC.


How Can I Find Affordable Car Insurance In Fayetteville, NC?

To find affordable car insurance in Fayetteville, NC, assess your unique needs. Research well-established companies like Erie, State Farm, and Beem. Compare quotes online and consider coverage types and local driving conditions.

What Factors Influence Car Insurance Rates In Fayetteville, NC?

Several factors influence car insurance rates in Fayetteville, NC. These include age, car makes and model, driving record, yearly mileage, credit history, zip code, marital status, and gender. Understanding these factors helps drivers make informed decisions and save on premiums.

How Do I Report A Car Insurance Claim In Fayetteville, NC?

After a car accident in Fayetteville, NC, follow the North Carolina Department of Insurance’s checklist. Move your vehicle to a safe place, contact Fayetteville Police for reportable accidents, and be cautious when speaking with insurance adjusters. Your vehicle insurance company will assign a claims adjuster to guide you.

How Can I Get A Personalized Car Insurance Quote In Fayetteville, NC?

To get a personalized car insurance quote in Fayetteville, NC, consider using online tools provided by companies like Beem. Input your information, including vehicle details and driving history, to receive quotes tailored to your specific needs and budget.

Was this helpful?

Did you like the post or would you like to give some feedback? Let us know your opinion by clicking one of the buttons below!



Picture of Aniket Kulkarni

Aniket Kulkarni

A seasoned Product Manager specializing in car insurance content, Aniket has a passion for simplifying complex insurance concepts. His strategic approach to content development reflects years of experience in the product development industry, coupled with a commitment to providing accurate, reliable information.


This page is purely informational. Beem does not provide financial, legal or accounting advice. This article has been prepared for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide financial, legal or accounting advice and should not be relied on for the same. Please consult your own financial, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transactions.

Related Posts
Can You Drive a Car Without Plates After Buying It? 
Can You Drive a Car Without Plates After Buying It? 
Many states consider driving a car without plates unlawful after purchasing it. Therefore, temporary plates or registrations are needed until permanent ones can be secured. Know more on how to comply with these requirements to avoid penalties, legal issues, and insurance hassles.
Why Do You Need Car Insurance
Why Do You Need Car Insurance ? – Know the Reasons
In most states, buying car insurance is required by law. It is a crucial way to protect yourself and your family from the potential costs of a major accident claim.
Does Auto Insurance Cover Theft
Does Car Insurance Cover Theft? [2024]
Auto insurance helps you cover the loss in these various types of accidents and thefts by giving necessary coverage. The blog aims to equip you with valuable insights to help you make informed decisions about protecting your vehicle from theft risks.
rental car insurance
Best Options For Rental Car Insurance
If you have rented a car, make sure you buy the company’s rental car insurance. However, if you already have vehicle insurance, you are likely covered up to your policy’s limits.
car insurance for high-risk drivers
Best Car Insurance for High-Risk Drivers
High-risk drivers often contend with higher insurance premiums due to their increased likelihood of filing claims. Let’s explore the best choices for car insurance for high-risk drivers.
car insurance for veterans
Best Car Insurance For Veterans
With various insurance providers offering tailored discounts and specialized coverage, veterans can easily find affordable and comprehensive vehicle protection. Read on to learn all about car insurance for veterans.

Get up to $1,000 for emergencies

Send money to anyone in the US

Ger personalized financial insights

Monitor and grow credit score

Save up to 40% on car insurance

Get up to $1,000 for loss of income

Insure up to $1 Million

Coming Soon

File federal and state taxes at low cost

Quick estimate of your tax returns

Get up to $1,000 for emergencies

Send money to anyone in the US

Save big on auto insurance - compare quotes now!

Zip Code:
Zip Code: