Best Car Insurance In Fort Collins

While location plays a significant role in determining car insurance rates, other factors like your driving history, vehicle type, and credit score also contribute to variations in premiums. Read on to learn all about the world of car insurance in Fort Collins.
car insurance in Fort Collins
Best Car Insurance In Fort Collins
When exploring options for the best car insurance in Fort Collins, researching and comparing insurance providers is critical to finding reliable coverage that fits individual needs and budgets.
In this article

Securing the best car insurance in Fort Collins involves considering various factors. Notable options include Beem, a guide that streamlines the process with personalized quotes within five minutes, and GEICO, offering competitive rates starting at $636 annually. State Farm has an extensive network and an average premium of $965 per year. Nationwide provides comprehensive coverage options, and American National Insurance Company offers flexibility with full coverage at $758 yearly. Evaluate these choices to find the best fit for your needs in Fort Collins.


Fort Collins, home to a lively population of 355k and a place known as the Craft Beer Capital of Colorado, has a lively atmosphere. As more people hit the roads in the city, car accidents are on the rise, affecting the cost of auto insurance. However, locals need to find the right coverage in this busy place where good driving matters in the city. It’s wise to team up with an auto insurance company that cares about safe habits more than just your age or where you live.

Most insurance companies decide how much you pay based on age, gender, marriage status, and ZIP code. But in Fort Collins, it’s about appreciating safe driving. Let’s look into car insurance options in Fort Collins, ensuring people here can drive confidently and financially safely on the busy streets of this thriving city.

Overview Of Car Insurance In Fort Collins

In Fort Collins, car insurance allows drivers to secure reliable coverage at competitive rates. As of October 2022, the average annual cost of auto insurance in Fort Collins is $857, showcasing affordability compared to the state and national averages. Surpassing the Colorado average by $145, Fort Collins residents enjoy a cost-effective option, notably $408 less expensive than the national average.

These rates reflect full coverage insurance policies with bodily injury liability limits set at $100,000 per person, $300,000 per accident, and $100,000 per accident for property damage. While location plays a significant role in determining car insurance rates, other factors such as driving history, vehicle type, and credit score also contribute to variations in premiums. Thus, drivers must explore their options and leverage available discounts to secure the most suitable and affordable coverage in Fort Collins.

Top 5 Car Insurance In Fort Collins

Securing the right car insurance in Fort Collins ensures peace of mind on the roads. Let’s explore the top 5 car insurance choices that stand out for their reliability, coverage options, and competitive rates.

  1. Beem
  2. Geico
  3. State Farm
  4. Nationwide
  5. American National Insurance Company


In Fort Collins, securing top-notch car insurance is a breeze with Beem. Revolutionizing the car insurance landscape, Beem offers personalized quotes from major providers within 5 minutes, simplifying the process and saving you hundreds annually in Fort Collins. Critical factors influencing rates include your vehicle’s make, driving history, age, and credit score, underscoring the importance of informed decision-making regarding car insurance.

Beem’s intuitive online platform empowers you to compare rates effectively, ensuring comprehensive coverage for all aspects, including vehicle damage, property damage, and personal injuries. While additional coverage options can enhance protection, Beem assists in navigating choices that align with your budget, making the selection process seamless and tailored to your needs. With Beem, car insurance isn’t just a choice; it’s a necessity met with convenience and efficiency in Fort Collins.


In Fort Collins, GEICO is a premier choice for residents seeking comprehensive and affordable car insurance. With an average annual cost of $1,218, GEICO offers competitive rates and many benefits, making it a preferred option in the insurance landscape.

GEICO’s appeal in Fort Collins lies in its competitive rates while maintaining coverage. Offering full coverage options with an average yearly premium of $636 or $53 per month and minimum coverage plans starting at $300 yearly or $25 monthly, GEICO ensures drivers can find a suitable plan tailored to their needs and budget. Additionally, GEICO prioritizes customer convenience with user-friendly online tools, enabling Fort Collins residents to manage policies, access resources, and obtain quotes seamlessly. With various discounts available and opportunities to bundle policies for additional savings, GEICO is a reliable and cost-effective choice for car insurance in Fort Collins.

State Farm

In Fort Collins, securing top-notch car insurance is easy with State Farm. As the nation’s largest auto insurance company, State Farm commands a substantial 16% market share, underlining its influence and reliability. State Farm offers an average full coverage premium of $80 per month or $965 per year, with competitive rates and an extensive network of 158 offices across North Carolina.

Choosing State Farm in Fort Collins has several advantages, including its market leader status, affordable rates, and a seamless digital experience. State Farm’s comprehensive coverage options cater to various needs, ensuring accessibility and reliability for those seeking dependable car insurance in Fort Collins. Whether you prefer in-person interactions or a digital approach, State Farm provides a versatile solution with highly-rated mobile tools for easy policy management, claims filing, payments, and roadside assistance.


When it comes to securing top-tier car insurance in Fort Collins, Nationwide emerges as a leading choice. What makes Nationwide Auto Insurance a reliable option for drivers in Fort Collins?

Nationwide offers a range of coverage options to suit various needs and budgets. From minimum car insurance plans starting at $400 yearly or $33 monthly to comprehensive coverage at $898 yearly or $75 monthly, Nationwide ensures drivers can find a plan that fits their requirements. Moreover, Nationwide is committed to being “On Your Side,” providing a trustworthy claims service for quick and efficient resolution when needed most. The Vanishing Deductible program rewards safe driving habits by reducing deductibles over time, while the On Your Side Auto Repair Network guarantees quality repair service. With innovative programs like SmartRide and SmartMiles offering discounts based on driving behavior, Nationwide ensures a reliable and reassuring car insurance experience for drivers in Fort Collins.

American National Insurance Company

In Fort Collins, American National Insurance Company is a top contender for reliable car insurance coverage. American National Insurance Company provides flexibility and affordability to drivers in Fort Collins, offering full coverage and minimum coverage options.

American National Insurance Company offers full coverage plans for those seeking comprehensive protection with an average yearly premium of $758 or $63 per month. Alternatively, minimum coverage plans are available for budget-conscious individuals with an average yearly premium of $383 or $32 per month. With competitive rates and a commitment to customer satisfaction, American National Insurance Company ensures peace of mind for drivers in Fort Collins. 

Car Insurance Requirements In Fort Collins

Knowing the state’s car insurance requirements is crucial if you own and drive a car in Fort Collins, Colorado. Colorado mandates that all drivers purchase auto insurance with specific minimum coverage amounts from an authorized insurance provider within the state. The mandatory coverage includes:

Minimum Liability Coverage:

  • $25,000 for Bodily Injury (per person)
  • $50,000 for Bodily Injury (per accident, multiple people injured)
  • $15,000 for Property Damage (per accident)

Minimum Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage:

  • $25,000 for Bodily Injury (per person)
  • $50,000 for Bodily Injury (per accident, multiple people injured)

While meeting these minimum requirements is essential, it’s advisable to consider purchasing higher coverage levels for better protection in case of an accident. Although it may increase your monthly premium, the added coverage ensures enhanced security on the road.

Types Of Car Insurance Coverage In Fort Collins

In Fort Collins, residents are presented with numerous choices for car insurance to ensure they’re adequately safeguarded while driving. Here’s an overview of the available coverage options:

Liability Coverage

Bodily injury (BI) liability insurance covers medical expenses for other drivers and passengers if you’re deemed at fault in an accident.

Property damage (PD) liability insurance addresses damages to other drivers’ vehicles in similar circumstances.

Collision Coverage

Collision coverage provides financial protection when your vehicle sustains damage due to collisions, offering reassurance in situations involving other vehicles or unexpected road hazards.

Comprehensive Coverage

Comprehensive coverage extends beyond collisions, safeguarding against a broader range of incidents such as damages from natural causes, theft, or vandalism.

Medical Payments Coverage (MedPay)

MedPay is crucial, offering coverage for medical bills post-accident and alleviating concerns about healthcare expenses.

Personal Injury Protection (PIP)

PIP delivers comprehensive protection by covering medical bills and potentially compensating for lost wages, bolstering financial security following an accident.

Underinsured/Uninsured Motorist Coverage (UM/UIM)

This coverage shields you in an accident involving an underinsured or uninsured driver, encompassing property damages (UMPD/UIMPD) and bodily injuries (UMBI/UIMBI) for you and your passengers.

Car Insurance In Fort Collins

Factors Influencing Car Insurance Rates In Fort Collins

A multitude of factors can impact car insurance rates significantly. Understanding these factors can help residents of Fort Collins make informed decisions when selecting their car insurance coverage. Here’s a breakdown of some key influencers:

Driving Record

Your driving history plays a big role in determining your car insurance rates. A clean record with no accidents or violations typically lowers premiums. In contrast, a history of accidents or speeding tickets may lead to higher rates.

Age and Gender

Younger drivers, especially teenagers and male drivers, statistically pose a higher risk on the road, which often translates to higher insurance premiums. Insurance companies consider age and gender when calculating rates.

Vehicle Type and Value

The type of car you drive, and its value affects your insurance rates. Luxury and sports vehicles usually come with higher premiums. This is because of their increased cost of repair or replacement.


The area where you live also impacts your insurance rates. Urban areas like Fort Collins may have higher rates due to increased traffic congestion and a higher likelihood of accidents or theft.

Credit Score

Insurance companies often use credit scores as a factor in determining rates. A higher credit score may result in lower premiums, as it is seen as an indicator of financial responsibility.

Coverage Options

The level of coverage you choose also influences your insurance rates. Opting for comprehensive coverage with lower deductibles will typically result in higher premiums, while basic coverage may reduce costs.

Finding The Right Car Insurance Provider In Fort Collins

Finding the right provider for car insurance in Fort Collins is crucial for peace of mind. Here’s a brief overview of rates and tips for choosing the best provider:

Rates in Fort Collins

Car insurance rates in Fort Collins can vary based on driving record, age, vehicle type, and coverage options. Urban areas often see higher premiums due to increased traffic and risks.

To find the right provider, compare quotes from multiple insurance companies. Consider factors like customer service, coverage options, and discounts offered. Look for providers with a good reputation for claims handling and customer satisfaction.

Reviewing your coverage needs regularly and adjusting your policy accordingly is also essential. You can find the right car insurance provider in Fort Collins to meet your needs and budget by researching and staying informed.

Researching Local Insurance Companies

For auto insurance in Fort Collins, some research goes a long way in finding the best fit for your needs. Various insurance companies factor in your driving history, vehicle, and location to determine rates, resulting in significant price variations.

For those seeking comprehensive coverage, MoneyGeek ranks American National P&C as the top choice, scoring 83 out of 100, offering an affordable annual premium of $462. GEICO, scoring 68 out of 100, is another contender with an annual premium of $636. American National P&C excels in affordability, customer satisfaction, and coverage variety, a rare trifecta in the insurance industry.

If you’re a member of the military, considering USAA is prudent. When researching local insurance companies in Fort Collins, compare rates and coverage options, allowing you to drive confidently with the right insurance for your specific circumstances.

Comparing Coverage

Compared to car insurance in Fort Collins, understanding the coverage options and associated rates is critical to making an informed decision. Here’s a breakdown of providers offering both minimum liability and full coverage policies:

Minimum Liability Car Insurance

For budget-conscious individuals seeking minimum coverage, American National P&C leads the pack with an annual premium of $179, closely followed by Colorado Farm Bureau at $247. On the other end, Allstate tops the list as the priciest option at $595 annually. Notably, American National P&C also boasts the most economical auto insurance in Colorado at $216 yearly as of October 2022, indicating favorable rates for Fort Collins residents compared to the state average.

CompanyAnnual PremiumMonthly Premium
American National P&C$179$15
Colorado Farm Bureau$247$21
Auto-Owners Insurance Co$305$25
State Farm$350$29
Table 1.0. Minimum Liability Car Insurance In Fort Collins

Cheapest Full Coverage Car Insurance

For those opting for comprehensive protection, American National P&C remains a frontrunner with an annual premium of $462. At the same time, GEICO follows closely at $636. Acuity is the highest-priced full-coverage insurer in Fort Collins, charging $1,148 annually. American National P&C also secures the title of the most affordable full-coverage auto insurance provider in Colorado, offering coverage at $541 annually as of October 2022. Understanding these options empowers residents to choose coverage that aligns with their needs and budget.

CompanyAnnual PremiumMonthly Premium
American National P&C$462$39
Colorado Farm Bureau$675$56
State Farm$798$67
Auto-Owners Insurance Co$854$71
Table 1.1. Full Coverage Car Insurance In Fort Collins

Filing A Car Insurance Claim In Fort Collins

When faced with the aftermath of an accident in Fort Collins, filing a car insurance claim can seem daunting. Here’s a guide to streamline the process and maximize your chances of a fair resolution:

Act Promptly

The crucial first step is prompt action. File your car insurance claim immediately after the incident occurs. Gather essential documents such as hospital bills, police accident reports, and copies of submitted claims to ensure a smooth process.

Document Conversations

Maintain meticulous notes of every interaction with insurance company representatives. Record the date, time, and specifics of each conversation. This keeps you informed about your claim’s progress and fosters clear communication.

Seek Assistance if Needed

If challenges arise or your claim needs to be handled more fairly, contact the state insurance regulator for guidance. Their intervention can ensure a fair resolution and assist if the process becomes complex.

Consider Legal Support

When your claim requires extra attention, consulting with a qualified attorney specializing in insurance claims is an option. They can advocate on your behalf, ensuring you receive the compensation entitled under your policy.

Tips For Lowering Car Insurance Costs In Fort Collins

Cutting down on car insurance expenses is achievable by leveraging the right discounts. Consider these straightforward strategies to reduce your car insurance expenditures in Fort Collins:

Combine Your Policies

Explore bundling your home, life, and auto insurance under a single provider. Many insurers provide discounts when you combine multiple policies, offering a comprehensive solution to minimize overall expenses.

Opt for Higher Deductibles

Choosing a higher deductible can result in reduced monthly premiums. Although it involves a higher out-of-pocket payment in case of a claim, this can be a strategic decision for individuals aiming to decrease their total insurance outlays.

Utilize Available Discounts

Investigate diverse discounts, including military discounts for active-duty service members and their families, good student discounts for young drivers with a B average or higher, and safe drivers for those maintaining a clean driving record.

Inquire with Your Provider

Discount offerings vary among companies, making you eligible for more than you know. It’s crucial to inquire with your insurance provider about available discounts, enabling you to identify and capitalize on those applicable to your situation. Seizing these opportunities effectively curtail your car insurance costs and result in long-term savings.


In conclusion, choosing the right car insurance in Fort Collins is a crucial decision for every driver. By understanding the local dynamics and legal requirements, residents can ensure they’re adequately protected on the road. Researching and comparing insurance providers is critical to finding reliable coverage that fits individual needs and budgets.

While basic insurance is essential, additional coverage options can provide security and confidence for Fort Collins residents. Factors like medical coverage, rental cars, and towing services can offer peace of mind in unexpected situations. It’s essential to explore various options, consult with local agents, and compare prices to make informed decisions about auto insurance in Fort Collins. Utilizing online tools like Beem and seeking professional guidance can help drivers navigate the insurance landscape confidently and confidently on the city’s bustling streets.


How can I find affordable car insurance in Fort Collins?

To find affordable car insurance in Fort Collins, compare quotes from multiple providers, consider discounts, and choose coverage that meets your needs without unnecessary extras. Utilizing online tools like Beem can streamline the process.

What factors influence car insurance rates in Fort Collins?

Car insurance rates in Fort Collins are influenced by driving record, age, vehicle type, credit score, and coverage options. Insurers also consider the local area, with urban locations often having higher premiums.

How do I report a car insurance claim in Fort Collins?

Promptly file your car insurance claim in Fort Collins by collecting essential documents like hospital bills and police reports. Document every conversation with insurance representatives and seek assistance from the state insurance regulator if needed. Legal support is an option for complex claims.

How can I get a personalized car insurance quote in Fort Collins?

To get a personalized car insurance quote in Fort Collins, use online tools like Beem, which provides quotes from major providers within 5 minutes. Consider your vehicle’s make, driving history, age, and credit score for accurate quotes tailored to your needs.

Was this helpful?

Did you like the post or would you like to give some feedback? Let us know your opinion by clicking one of the buttons below!



Picture of Aniket Kulkarni

Aniket Kulkarni

A seasoned Product Manager specializing in car insurance content, Aniket has a passion for simplifying complex insurance concepts. His strategic approach to content development reflects years of experience in the product development industry, coupled with a commitment to providing accurate, reliable information.


This page is purely informational. Beem does not provide financial, legal or accounting advice. This article has been prepared for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide financial, legal or accounting advice and should not be relied on for the same. Please consult your own financial, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transactions.

Related Posts
Can You Drive a Car Without Plates After Buying It? 
Can You Drive a Car Without Plates After Buying It? 
Many states consider driving a car without plates unlawful after purchasing it. Therefore, temporary plates or registrations are needed until permanent ones can be secured. Know more on how to comply with these requirements to avoid penalties, legal issues, and insurance hassles.
Why Do You Need Car Insurance
Why Do You Need Car Insurance ? – Know the Reasons
In most states, buying car insurance is required by law. It is a crucial way to protect yourself and your family from the potential costs of a major accident claim.
Does Auto Insurance Cover Theft
Does Car Insurance Cover Theft? [2024]
Auto insurance helps you cover the loss in these various types of accidents and thefts by giving necessary coverage. The blog aims to equip you with valuable insights to help you make informed decisions about protecting your vehicle from theft risks.
rental car insurance
Best Options For Rental Car Insurance
If you have rented a car, make sure you buy the company’s rental car insurance. However, if you already have vehicle insurance, you are likely covered up to your policy’s limits.
car insurance for high-risk drivers
Best Car Insurance for High-Risk Drivers
High-risk drivers often contend with higher insurance premiums due to their increased likelihood of filing claims. Let’s explore the best choices for car insurance for high-risk drivers.
car insurance for veterans
Best Car Insurance For Veterans
With various insurance providers offering tailored discounts and specialized coverage, veterans can easily find affordable and comprehensive vehicle protection. Read on to learn all about car insurance for veterans.

Get up to $1,000 for emergencies

Send money to anyone in the US

Ger personalized financial insights

Monitor and grow credit score

Save up to 40% on car insurance

Get up to $1,000 for loss of income

Insure up to $1 Million

Coming Soon

File federal and state taxes at low cost

Quick estimate of your tax returns

Get up to $1,000 for emergencies

Send money to anyone in the US

Save big on auto insurance - compare quotes now!

Zip Code:
Zip Code: