How Much Does Car Insurance Cost? A Comprehensive Guide

Every car insurance company decides the cost of your policy on the basis of a wide array of factors, including the state you reside in, driving history, vehicle and demographics. It helps the companies in making educated decision on how likely you are to file a claim and confirming the prices accordingly. Let’s discuss how certain factors can impact the cost of your car insurance.
how much does car insurance cost
How Much Does Car Insurance Cost? A Comprehensive Guide
It is essential to know the average cost of car insurance to make an informed decision on your personalized insurance policy. This guide will help in understanding how certain factors affect the cost of your car insurance policy.
In this article

Car insurance cost is almost as unique as your fingerprint. Although your circumstances may seem similar, several personalized rating factors differentiate your premium rates from your friends, neighbors, family members, and the national average.

Car insurance in the U.S. can cost an average of $2,014 per year, with minimum coverage costing $622. This rate includes liability, comprehensive, collision, and additional coverage that drivers must carry in their state. It is essential to know the average cost of car insurance to make an informed decision on your personalized insurance policy. It allows you to pay a competitive rate for your car insurance. 

However, your car insurance cost will vary depending on several factors. Let’s break down some of the factors and how they affect your rates in this blog.

How Your State Impacts Car Insurance Rates?

The state where you live, its accident and claim reporting frequency, and the cost of labor and parts can be more expensive than others. For instance, Vermont, Idaho, New Hampshire, Maine, and Massachusetts have the cheapest auto insurance rates. These states have a comparatively lower cost of living, lesser likelihood of accidents and claims, and less traffic congestion in these regions.

On the other hand, drivers in New York, Florida, Kentucky, Louisiana, Michigan, Rhode Island, and Nevada can expect a higher average cost of car insurance. It could be due to frequent claims, making drivers riskier to insure overall.

Car Insurance Costs by Driving History

Getting caught drinking and driving will increase your car insurance cost significantly. On average, the rates can go up by about 83% for a driver with a recent DUI. The average increase in Connecticut, Michigan, and North Carolina is more than $4,000 annually. Also, car insurance rates get about 50% higher for drivers after an at-fault accident. In that case, it is better to shop for car insurance quotes after three to five years of the accident to find a better deal.

Average car insurance costs based on driving history:

Type of policyClean recordRecent DUIAfter one at-fault accident
Full coverage$2,148$3,933$3,164
Minimum coverage$685 $1,403$1,044

Switching to the minimum required insurance coverage in your state can lessen the blow of a high premium, though better choices exist. You can lower costs if you shop for the cheapest auto insurance after a DUI. Each insurance company has different considerations when setting prices in case of a crash.

You will want collision insurance if you seek coverage after an at-fault accident. Moreover, you may be required to maintain collision and comprehensive insurance coverages in case you took a loan on your car.

Car Insurance Costs by Driving History
How Much Does Car Insurance Cost? A Comprehensive Guide 4

How Credit Score Affects Car Insurance Rates?

Poor credit has a significant impact on car insurance rates in most states. Short credit history can damage your credit-based insurance score, raising your vehicle insurance prices. For drivers with bad credit, the average increase in vehicle insurance costs is more than 61%. However, credit scores are not allowed to be used by insurers in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, or Michigan to calculate auto insurance prices.

Average car insurance prices for people with bad credit:

Type of policyGood credit Poor credit       
Full coverage$2,148$3,455
Minimum coverage$685$1,118

Does Age Impact Car Insurance Rates?

Insurers see less experienced drivers as a more considerable risk, typically charging them heftier premiums. Insurers categorize anyone between 16 and 25 or 30 as a young driver. As you age past your 30s, rates tend to go down. It gets higher again after 70 due to age-related health conditions that may impact the driving behavior of those above 70.

The average car insurance cost is $4,372 for full coverage ($1,491 for minimum necessary coverage) for a 20-year-old driver with a good credit score and a clean driving record. Those with bad credit or poor driving records might have to pay more.

Car Insurance Cost by Vehicle Type

Your car insurance rates are affected by the make and model of your vehicle. Insurers tend to charge higher prices to cover certain cars, including sports models, which generally have higher top speeds and an increased likelihood of a crash or traffic violation. Luxury cars and electric vehicles are costlier in terms of insurance as they have expensive parts and details that are difficult to replace. Popular car models more likely to be stolen also attract higher rates for comprehensive insurance.

Car Insurance Cost by Vehicle Type
How Much Does Car Insurance Cost? A Comprehensive Guide 5

Car Insurance Prices by Gender

Gender is a major contributing factor for premiums in a majority of states. Men typically cost more to insure compared to women as they are considered risky drivers. However, some states, including California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania, prohibit this rating factor.

What else affects the price of car insurance? Some additional factors considered for quoting insurance rates are occupation, marital status, level of education, previous insurance company, continuity in insurance coverage, annual mileage driven per car, home ownership, and additional coverages.

How To Lower the Cost of Car Insurance?

Here are some effective strategies to help you lower the price of your car insurance and save some money in the long run. 

  • Shop around: It is essential to compare rates from several insurers, especially when changes impact your rates.
  • Bundle Plans: Experts advise bundling your insurance plans, such as home or medical insurance policies, to get the best premium discounts. 
  • Pay upfront: Several insurance companies offer a discount if you pay the entire premium, making it a cost-effective option.
  • Take a driving safety class: Every state offers driver safety programs approved by the authorities. If you take these classes, typically 6-8 hours long, insurers offer discounts after completing the programs.
  • Use a monitoring app: Insurance providers often provide usage-based discounts when you let them monitor your driving habits. Use tracking apps to check aspects like braking distance, average speed, and driving times.
  • Reduce coverage: With your vehicle aging, you may not need comprehensive and collision insurance coverages. You can drop certain coverages from your policy to reduce your overall cost.


You may have concluded that the average car insurance cost depends on many factors, and no matter how many averages you look at, your rates will likely be different. Indeed, the average cost of car insurance is rising thanks to record inflation, unprecedented supply chain issues, and increased post-pandemic claims.

Did your rates go up, too? There’s no assurance that your insurance rate go up (or down) in 2023 due to the highly personalized nature of car insurance prices. You should prepare for your car insurance rate and shop around for your preferred quotes to get a lower premium.

Was this helpful?

Did you like the post or would you like to give some feedback? Let us know your opinion by clicking one of the buttons below!



Nivedita Majumdar

Nivedita Majumdar

A journalist at heart, Nivedita is a passionate storyteller who thrives on informing readers about what matters to them. When not typing away on her keyboard, she is looking to savor new life experiences (on budget)!


This page is purely informational. Beem does not provide financial, legal or accounting advice. This article has been prepared for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide financial, legal or accounting advice and should not be relied on for the same. Please consult your own financial, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transactions.

Related Posts
Best Car Insurance for College Students
For many students, heading to college opens up newer avenues of freedom and can also imply buying a car. The privilege of having a car comes with the responsibility of securing car insurance – a non-negotiable necessity.
Best Car Insurance For Seniors
Looking for the best and perfect car insurance for seniors? You need to consider factors such as driving experience, health, offered discounts, among others, for optimal coverage. 
Best Car Insurance for Full Coverage
Full-coverage insurance is a must for every driver. If you want to explore the top contenders in the market, this article is for you. Let's help you decide on the best car insurance for full coverage.
Best Car Insurance for New Drivers
While insurers don't offer special car insurance for teen drivers, they might charge a slightly higher premium. The coverage is based on driving experience, and as teen drivers lack experience behind the wheel, they might have to pay more. Read to know more.
Motorcycle Insurance vs Car Insurance
Best Car Insurance for Young Drivers
Young drivers need the right insurance policy at the right price. In this article, you'll learn about various insurance providers who offer affordable policies.
Best Cars to Insure for Young Drivers
In this article, you will understand the safest and most affordable list of vehicles for your teens. After all, which parent wouldn't want to provide their younger ones a safer driving and learning experience.

Get up to $1,000 for emergencies

Send money to anyone in the US

Ger personalized financial insights

Monitor and grow credit score

Save up to 40% on car insurance

Get up to $1,000 for loss of income

Insure up to $1 Million

Coming Soon

File federal and state taxes at low cost

Quick estimate of your tax returns

Get up to $1,000 for emergencies

Send money to anyone in the US

Save big on auto insurance - compare quotes now!

Zip Code:
Zip Code: