What to Do If Car Is Not Fixed Properly After Insurance Claim 

If your car is not fixed properly after insurance claim, it can be a tiresome process. This blog will help explain the process of getting your car restored to the pre-accident condition if it’s not fixed properly at the repair shop even after an insurance claim.
What to Do If Car Is Not Fixed Properly After Insurance Claim
What to Do If Car Is Not Fixed Properly After Insurance Claim 
While driving your repaired car back home from the shop, do you experience some engine issues or rattling sounds? It can raise one concern: What should you do if your car is not fixed properly after insurance claim? Let's find out!
In this article

Getting your car repaired after an unprecedented accident can be both stressful and expensive. Furthermore, going through the car insurance claims process can be tiresome.

After the car is fixed, you pick it up from the repair shop. However, while driving it back home, you experience some engine issues or rattling sounds. Such a situation raises one pertinent question: What should you do if your damaged car is not fixed properly after insurance claim? This blog will help explain the process of getting your car restored to the pre-accident condition if it’s not fixed properly at the repair shop.

What to Do When Accident Damage is Not Properly Repaired

There are some steps that you can take if your car is not fixed properly after insurance claim:

1. Talk to the Repair Shop

Insurers assign an adjuster to a claim when you begin the claim settlement. As the repair process advances, you will work with your insurer. You should contact your repairer if you face any problems with your repairs.

Your insurer is obligated to pay for the cost of fixing your car until it is returned to its pre-loss state. If, for example, the body shop did not restore your bumper, it is logical for the insurer to permit additional repairs.

2. Request a Post-Repair Inspection

A post-repair assessment can determine whether your car was repaired properly after an accident. You can contact a different mechanic if you suspect the repair shop wasn’t honest with you or didn’t correctly diagnose the problem.

If any other problem is discovered during the inspection, they should be covered by insurance if they resulted from the same incident.

3. Contact Car Insurance Company

Contact your auto insurance provider to explore the issue further if you find additional concerns after repair. Considering they are paying for the repairs, it is in their best interest to ensure the repairs are made correctly and that the claim is processed without concerns.

Whether it’s the ability to retract a payment or the threat of removing the body shop from their list of pre-approved service providers, your insurance company may have the resources you need. It will further encourage the body shop to correct their errors. 

Other Ways to Challenge an Insurance Claim

If your insurance company denies your request for further repairs and the repair shop denies wrongdoing, you may have other options. You can restore your car to its pre-loss condition by following these steps. 

1. File a Complaint

If you have a complaint against your insurance company, contact your state’s Department of Insurance. Alternatively, you can contact your state’s Bureau of Auto Repair.

2. Contact an Attorney

Hire an attorney specializing in insurance disputes for more costly insurance claims. If the claim is denied, the attorney may be able to file a lawsuit and force the insurer to pay the compensation you are entitled to under the insurance policy.

How to Tell if Car Repairs Were Done Right

A repair can be hard to judge if it was done correctly. Nevertheless, you can check your car after an accident to ensure it was properly repaired.

1. Ask for a Copy of the Vehicle History Report

Obtain a vehicle history report from a reputable source like Carfax or AutoCheck. Check for any reported accidents, damages, or title issues. Examine the maintenance records for evidence of regular servicing and post-accident repairs. Ensure repairs were performed by certified technicians using genuine parts.

2. Test the Paint Job

  • Consistency: Inspect the paint’s color consistency across all panels. Inconsistencies might indicate a mismatch due to poor repair work.
  • Texture: Run your hand over the painted surfaces. A smooth, even texture is ideal. Rough or uneven areas may suggest subpar paintwork.
  • Panel Alignment: Check for any misalignment between panels, as this may indicate issues related to the repair or repainting process.
  • Blending: Look for signs of blending, where the new paint seamlessly merges with the existing paint. Poor blending can be a sign of rushed or inadequate repair work.

3. Find Aftermarket Parts

  • Review Repair Invoice: Check the repair invoice for details on the parts used. If aftermarket parts were used, they should be high quality and suitable for your vehicle.
  • Inspect for OEM Markings: Examine replaced components for original equipment manufacturer (OEM) markings. Authentic parts usually bear these markings.
  • Research Parts Compatibility: Verify that aftermarket parts are compatible with your vehicle’s make and model. Incompatible parts can lead to performance issues.

4. Look for Putty Resin

  • Check for Uneven Surfaces: Run your hand over repaired areas to detect uneven surfaces. Putty resin may be used to fill dents, but poor application can result in irregularities.
  • Tap for Solidity: Gently tap on repaired areas. A solid, consistent sound suggests proper repair, while a hollow or different sound may indicate the use of excessive putty.
  • Visual Inspection: Inspect the repaired areas under good lighting conditions. Look for signs of cracks, bubbles or an uneven finish, which can indicate improper use of putty resin.

If you’re not confident in your assessment, consider a professional inspection from a trusted mechanic or a collision repair specialist. They can provide a more thorough evaluation of the repair work done on the vehicle.

What to Do if You Suspect Repairs Were Done Poorly

You can take steps to ensure that your accident damages are fully repaired if they haven’t been repaired properly.

1. Consult the Repair Shop

Getting in touch with the repair shop is your first step. To discuss specific issues, speak with the manager. Describe what you noticed, heard, or felt when you drove your vehicle after the repairs. Some vehicles don’t have anything wrong with them.

You may also be asked to have the manager look at your vehicle again to ensure the repairs were done correctly.

2. Request a Post-Repair Inspection

During the post-repair inspection, the original damage is assessed and repaired to the owner’s satisfaction.

While collision repair inspections are free of charge in some states, you can hire a third party to inspect your home in others. If you want an assessment of the repairs after they are done, ask your insurance company’s adjuster.

3. Contact your Car Insurance Company

Contact your insurance company if an inspection proves the repairs were improperly done. No matter where your car was repaired, your insurance company must return it to pre-loss condition.

Under your insurance claim, you may be entitled to more repairs if the repair work was not done correctly.


If your car is not fixed properly after insurance claim, the insurer must continue paying for repairs until the car is restored to pre-loss condition. Inspect your repair after you have contacted your insurance company. Y

our insurance company should cover all remaining costs for repairing your car if the damages were legitimate and the vehicle genuinely needs more repairs. Don’t forget to check out Beem which helps you compare different car insurance options and find the best match in your budget.


1. What if my car insurance claim takes too long?

Consider involving your state’s insurance department if your car insurance claim is delayed, and contact your insurance company for updates.

2. What happens if my car can’t be fixed?

You can keep or surrender the salvage to the insurance company based on the car’s value before the accident, minus the deductible.

3. Can I just keep the money from an insurance claim?

You are usually free to use the money as you please once you get a payment from your insurance company. If you choose not to repair your car, driving it could be unsafe, and it will have a lower resell value.

Was this helpful?

Did you like the post or would you like to give some feedback? Let us know your opinion by clicking one of the buttons below!



Picture of Aniket Kulkarni

Aniket Kulkarni

A seasoned Product Manager specializing in car insurance content, Aniket has a passion for simplifying complex insurance concepts. His strategic approach to content development reflects years of experience in the product development industry, coupled with a commitment to providing accurate, reliable information.


This page is purely informational. Beem does not provide financial, legal or accounting advice. This article has been prepared for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide financial, legal or accounting advice and should not be relied on for the same. Please consult your own financial, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transactions.

Related Posts
Best Car Insurance in Lakeland, FL
Best Car Insurance in Lakeland, FL
In Lakeland, FL, the average yearly vehicle insurance cost is $2,154, providing insights for drivers navigating the market; read on to learn how to acquire ideal coverage at competitive prices!
Best Car Insurance in Killeen, TX
Best Car Insurance in Killeen, TX
In Killeen, TX, car insurance costs an average of $631 every six months, which is lower than the Texas and national averages - read on to learn how to get the best coverage at a reasonable cost!
Best Car Insurance in Jonesboro
Best Car Insurance in Jonesboro, AR
Car insurance premiums in Jonesboro, AR, average $1,744 per year, which is somewhat lower than the state average and determined by characteristics such as age, credit score, and driving history. Understanding local driving conditions and looking into discounts may greatly influence rates - read on to learn more!
car insurance in Hermosa
Best Car Insurance in Hermosa
Finding the right car insurance in Hermosa Beach, California, is critical for keeping yourself and your vehicle safe. Read on to know more.
Cheapest Car Insurance in West Virginia
Cheapest Car Insurance in West Virginia
Considering car insurance companies have different ways of calculating their premium for the best coverage, it is important to compare rates from multiple providers. This guide provides the necessary details to find the cheapest car insurance in West Virginia to help you make an informed decision.
car insurance in Chattanooga
Car Insurance In Chattanooga
Several factors influence car insurance in Chattanooga, including your driving record, age, type of vehicle, location, and credit score. Additionally, coverage options, deductibles, and insurance history can impact the cost of your premiums.

Get up to $1,000 for emergencies

Send money to anyone in the US

Ger personalized financial insights

Monitor and grow credit score

Save up to 40% on car insurance

Get up to $1,000 for loss of income

Insure up to $1 Million

Coming Soon

File federal and state taxes at low cost

Quick estimate of your tax returns

Get up to $1,000 for emergencies

Send money to anyone in the US

Save big on auto insurance - compare quotes now!

Zip Code:
Zip Code: