Renting a Car on Vacation? What Insurance Do You Need?

Vacations should be a time of relaxation, adventure, and discovery. Whether you’re road-tripping across the US, Europe’s countryside, or landing in a new city for a week-long getaway, renting a car often becomes the most practical choice. It gives you flexibility, freedom, and comfort — but also comes with a dreaded moment that almost every traveler encounters.

The agent asks if you want to add insurance coverage and throws terms at you. You glance at the paperwork and see daily costs of $20, $30, or more, and suddenly, your affordable rental car looks a lot less budget-friendly. Renting a car on vacation? What insurance do you need? This blog will answer those questions in detail. 

Understanding the Basics of Rental Car Insurance

What Rental Companies Typically Offer

When you rent a car, you’ll often be offered four main types of insurance or protection products:

1. Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) or Loss Damage Waiver (LDW):
   • Covers damage to or theft of the rental car.
   • Often waives your responsibility for repair or replacement costs.
   • Doesn’t cover injuries or liability to others.
   • Typically $10–$30 per day.
2. Liability Insurance Supplement (LIS):
   • Provides coverage if you injure someone else or damage their property while driving the rental.
   • States have minimum liability requirements in the US, but they’re often low. LIS increases your protection to $1 million or more.
3. Personal Accident Insurance (PAI):
   • Covers medical expenses for you and your passengers if injured in an accident.
   • Similar to health insurance or medical payments coverage in auto insurance.
4. Personal Effects Coverage (PEC):
   • Insures belongings stolen from the rental car.
   • Often redundant if you already have homeowners or renters insurance.

Why It Feels Confusing at the Counter

The rental counter is not designed for careful decision-making. You’re tired, eager to get going, and faced with a fast-talking representative whose job is partly to upsell insurance. Add in unfamiliar terms, daily costs, and vague warnings about risks, and it’s no wonder most travelers either overpay for unnecessary coverage or skip protection they actually need.

What Coverage Do You Already Have?

Before buying rental car insurance, check what protection you already have. Many drivers are surprised to learn they’re already covered through other sources.

Your Personal Car Insurance Policy

If you own a car in the US and have insurance, chances are it extends to rentals for personal use. This typically includes:

• Liability coverage (injuries or property damage you cause to others).
• Collision/comprehensive (if you have them on your policy, they usually apply to rentals as well).

Exceptions:

• Coverage may not extend to international rentals.
• Some policies exclude rentals used for business or commercial purposes.
• Deductibles and policy limits still apply.

Credit Card Coverage

Many credit cards — especially travel-focused ones — offer rental car insurance when you use the card to book and pay. However:

• Most cards offer secondary coverage, which kicks in only after your personal auto insurance pays.
• Some premium cards (e.g., certain Amex, Chase Sapphire, Capital One cards) offer primary coverage, meaning they cover the rental first, avoiding claims on your personal policy.
• Always read the fine print — exclusions may apply to certain car types (luxury, trucks, exotic cars) and certain countries.

Travel Insurance Policies

If you buy travel insurance for your trip, it may include coverage for rental cars. However, this coverage is often limited to collision damage, not liability, so you’d still need liability protection elsewhere.

International Travel Considerations

If you’re renting outside the US:

• Europe: Basic liability is often included by law, but CDW may be optional or mandatory.
• Latin America: Rental companies often require purchasing CDW from them, even if your card covers it.
• Asia: Coverage rules vary widely; always confirm before booking.

The key is to check your existing policies before traveling so you don’t buy redundant coverage.

Deep Dive Into Rental Insurance Options

Collision Damage Waiver (CDW/LDW)

What it covers: Damage or theft of the rental car. CDW/LDW essentially means the rental company won’t pursue you for repair costs.

What it doesn’t cover: Personal injuries, liability to others, or items inside the car.

Cost: $10–$30 per day. On a 7-day rental, this could add $210.

When it makes sense:

• You don’t have collision/comprehensive on your personal policy.
• You’re traveling internationally, and your U.S. policy doesn’t extend coverage.
• You want peace of mind and don’t want to risk disputes over minor damages.

Liability Insurance Supplement (LIS)

What it covers: Injury or property damage to others caused while driving the rental.

Why it matters: State minimum liability limits can be very low (e.g., $25,000 in some states). If you cause a serious accident, that’s not nearly enough. LIS increases liability protection to $1 million or more.

Cost: $10–$15 per day.

When it makes sense:

• You don’t already carry high liability limits on your personal policy.
• You’re traveling abroad, where liability coverage requirements differ.

Personal Accident Insurance (PAI)

What it covers: Medical expenses for you and passengers.

Why it may be unnecessary: Most people already have health insurance that covers accidents, and some auto policies include medical payments coverage.

Cost: $3–$5 per day.

Personal Effects Coverage (PEC)

What it covers: Theft of belongings from the rental car.

Why it may be redundant: Homeowners and renters policies often cover personal belongings, even away from home.

Cost: $2–$5 per day.

Common Myths About Rental Car Insurance

• Myth 1: You must buy coverage from the rental company.
  Reality: Many drivers already have coverage through personal auto insurance, credit cards, or travel insurance.
• Myth 2: Credit cards always cover rentals fully.
  Reality: Many provide only secondary coverage. Always confirm whether coverage is primary or secondary.
• Myth 3: My health insurance covers everything in a rental accident.
  Reality: Health insurance covers medical costs but not liability or car damage.
• Myth 4: International rentals are always covered under US policies.
  Reality: Most US auto policies don’t extend abroad. International rentals often require buying CDW locally.

Cost Analysis – Paying for Peace of Mind vs. Overpaying

How Much Daily Rental Insurance Costs

• CDW/LDW: $10–$30/day.
• LIS: $10–$15/day.
• PAI: $3–$5/day.
• PEC: $2–$5/day.

A $40/day rental can easily double in cost with add-ons.

Comparing Costs to Risks

Skipping CDW may save $200 on a week-long trip, but if you dent the car and repairs cost $2,000, you’ll wish you had coverage.

When Skipping Insurance Could Backfire

Real-world example: A traveler declined CDW, relying on their credit card. When the rental car was stolen abroad, their credit card didn’t cover theft in that country. They ended up paying $12,000 for the vehicle.

How to Decide What You Really Need

Step 1 – Check Your Existing Coverage

Review your personal auto policy, credit card benefits, and any travel insurance.

Step 2 – Consider Your Destination

In the U.S., your policy may suffice. Abroad, you may need to buy coverage.

Step 3 – Evaluate Your Risk Tolerance

Some travelers prefer peace of mind, even if it costs more. Others are comfortable with some risk to save money.

Step 4 – Run the Numbers

Compare daily costs to potential out-of-pocket risks. A $150 weekly coverage fee may be cheaper than a $5,000 liability.

Tips to Save Money on Rental Car Insurance

• Book with a credit card offering primary rental coverage.
• Bundle rental insurance with travel insurance for cheaper rates.
• Decline duplicate coverage if you already have it.
• Reserve so you can review terms calmly.
• Use tools like Beem, an AI-powered smart wallet app, to compare bundled insurance options and avoid overpaying.

Conclusion

Rental car insurance doesn’t need to be stressful. The key is preparation. Before your trip, review your personal auto policy, credit card benefits, and travel insurance. Decide what gaps you need to fill, and budget accordingly. With knowledge, you can confidently accept the coverage that matters and decline the rest. This balance saves you money while ensuring you’re protected from the unexpected.

By planning ahead and leveraging tools like Beem to compare coverage, you’ll hit the road with confidence — and enjoy your vacation without worrying about insurance fine print. Beem, the personal finance app trusted by over 5 million Americans, provides a convenient platform for comparing car insurance quotes and discovering affordable rates tailored to individual needs. You can take the first step towards securing reliable coverage today with Beem. Download the app here.

FAQs on Renting a Car on Vacation? What Insurance Do You Need?