Private Mortgage Insurance: How to Lower PMI and Remove It Faster

Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) is a financial penalty for purchasing a home with a down payment of less than 20%. For many US buyers, it’s a monthly reality that adds hundreds to their housing budget—even though it doesn’t protect them, but rather covers lenders in case of default. 

As real-estate and money coaches, we regularly guide clients through the tactics that don’t just save PMI dollars up front, but cut years off the PMI schedule—putting money back in your pocket faster. Use this comprehensive, step-by-step guide to lower PMI, hit removal milestones sooner, and unlock home equity with confidence.

Try Beem App that takes the stress out of managing your money. Whether you’re planning for a dream home or just trying to get a handle on your budget, Beem’s tools guide you along the way.

What Is PMI and When Is It Required?

Understanding PMI Basics

Private mortgage insurance (PMI) is a policy that most conventional lenders require when a borrower’s down payment is less than 20% of the home’s purchase price. FHA loans and some other programs have their own insurance requirements, but the mechanics are similar: less equity, more risk to the lender, so you pay for insurance on their behalf.

How PMI impacts you:

• Who pays? Homeowners with conventional loans and less than 20% down.
• Who benefits? Lenders, not homeowners (unlike hazard insurance).
• How is it charged? Usually monthly, but sometimes as a single up-front or split premium.
• How much does it cost? Typically, 0.5% to 1.5% of the original loan balance per year (that’s $125–$375 a month on a $300,000 mortgage).

PMI is not forever—if you know the rules and plan, you can shrink its burden and remove it as early as possible.

How Can You Lower PMI from the Start?

Strategies at Closing

1. Increase Your Down Payment (Even Slightly)

Putting just a little more down can dramatically reduce your PMI premium. Even if 20% seems impossible, reaching higher breakpoints (5%, 10%, 15%) often means lower monthly charges since PMI is tiered. Example: A buyer with a 5% down payment loan may pay a significantly higher PMI rate than one with a 10% or 15% down payment.

2. Boost Your Credit Score

PMI rates are credit-score sensitive. Raising your score from the mid-600s to the high 700s could cut your PMI in half, saving you thousands over the early years of your mortgage. Review and optimize your credit months before applying.

3. Shop Multiple Lenders

Not all lenders use the same PMI companies or price PMI the same way. One lender might offer a lower PMI rate based on your credit or down payment, so get quotes from at least three. Sometimes, the lowest interest rate isn’t the overall cheapest if the PMI is significantly higher.

4. Ask About Paid-Upfront or Split-Premium PMI

Some lenders offer the option to pay all or part of the PMI upfront, which can result in a lower monthly payment. If you plan to stay in the home long-term, this could save cash monthly. Evaluate the breakeven point before choosing.

5. Consider “Lender-Paid” or “Financed” PMI

Some loans have the lender pay PMI in exchange for a slightly higher interest rate. This makes sense for buyers expecting quick appreciation or plans to move/refinance soon, but it may cost more over the years if you stay for the long haul.

Comparing Loans

Evaluate PMI costs across loan products (FHA vs conventional) and structures (piggyback loans/80-10-10 vs single mortgage with PMI). Sometimes, new conventional programs for first-time buyers or those with high credit scores offer a cheaper deal, even with a lower down payment.

Piggyback Loans and Alternative Strategies

What Are Piggyback Loans?

A piggyback, or 80-10-10 loan, lets you combine:

• An 80% first mortgage
• A 10% second mortgage or HELOC
• A 10% down payment

This structure avoids PMI because your first mortgage is now below 80% of the value. Monthly savings can be significant, though second loans often have higher rates and variable terms. Always run the math on total payments and risk tolerance.

Lump-Sum (“Single-Premium”) PMI

If you have extra cash but not enough for a 20% down payment, ask if you can buy out PMI with a single upfront premium. This may work well if you plan to stay put and won’t need to refinance for several years.

Also Read: Property Taxes: How to Forecast Realistic Payments (US Homebuyer’s Guide)

How to Remove PMI Faster

The good news is that federal law (the Homeowners Protection Act) and most loan terms allow PMI to be canceled as you build equity.

Pay Down Principal Early

• Extra payments: Send in money toward the principal; even $50–$100 a month can cut interest and accelerate your path to 80% loan-to-value (LTV).
• Biweekly payments: Making half a mortgage payment every two weeks creates one full extra payment per year, speeding your equity growth.
• Windfalls, such as tax refunds, bonuses, or other unexpected cash, applied directly to principal can help you reach the critical 20% equity mark months or even years faster.

Refinance as Values Rise

If your local market appreciates quickly, your home’s value could increase much faster than the amortization schedule. Refinancing into a new conventional loan (with or without a cash-out option) re-bases your LTV and can eliminate PMI if the new appraisal puts you at or below 80% LTV.

• Consider closing costs, breakeven timelines, and projected rates before refinancing to ensure a smooth process. Sometimes, a simple PMI removal request is the best approach.

PMI Removal via Appraisal or Refinance

Appraisal-Driven Removal

• When to request: After paying down your loan OR if your property has appreciated enough that your loan balance is now 80% (or 75% in some cases) or less of your home’s market value.
• Process: Contact your loan servicer in writing, requesting PMI cancellation based on the increased value of your property. You’ll likely be required to pay for a professional appraisal.
• Payoff: Once they verify your new LTV, PMI can be cancelled—often within a single month.

Refinance to Remove PMI

• If market rates have dropped—or you want a new loan term—a refinance can help you shed PMI (plus lower your rate in some cases) once you meet the LTV threshold.
• Factor in the cost of new loan fees, appraisal, and potential prepayment penalties.
• This is ideal if your PMI is expensive, home values have increased significantly, or you need to change your ownership structure anyway.

When and How to Request PMI Cancellation

Standard Approaches

Automated Removal

• By law, your lender must automatically terminate PMI when your schedule (without extra payments) hits 78% LTV.

Borrower-Requested Cancellation

• When you reach 80% LTV (based on the original or current appraised value, depending on time elapsed and loan type), you can proactively request PMI removal.
• You’ll need to be current on your payments and may need to demonstrate that your property isn’t worth less than its original value.
• Contact customer service, provide a formal request in writing, and be prepared to provide supporting evidence (appraisal, payment history).

Extra Payments or Value Increases

• Don’t wait for automatic removal—calculate your own LTV monthly and time your request as soon as you qualify.\
• Keep records of all principal payments and request regular mortgage statements to ensure accurate tracking of your mortgage payments.

Also Read: Down Payment Assistance: Where to Find Real Programs for US Homebuyers

FHA and Special Program Considerations

FHA Mortgage Insurance (MIP)

Unlike conventional PMI, FHA’s mortgage insurance premium (MIP) cannot always be removed based on equity. For FHA loans:

• If your down payment was less than 10%, MIP stays for the life of the loan (unless you refinance).
• If you put down 10% or more, MIP may drop off after 11 years.

To escape MIP entirely:

• Refinance into a conventional mortgage when your LTV reaches 80% or less. This is a very smart move for buyers who expect strong appreciation or can pay down principal quickly.

Other Special Cases

VA loans do not require PMI, but do require an up-front funding fee. USDA loans have their own annual fee, typically lower than conventional PMI.

Tips for Ongoing PMI Savings

• Stay current on payments: Late or missed payments may delay or prevent PMI removal, even if you meet the equity requirements.
• Track your loan-to-value ratio: Use your lender’s online portal or mortgage calculator to follow your progress.
• Stay organized with statements: Keep records from closing and all major home improvements or appraisals, which can strengthen your case for current-value PMI removal.
• Annual check-ins: Mark your calendar or set a digital reminder each year to review your LTV status and the lender’s removal criteria.
• Avoid re-amortizing for new second mortgages or cash-out refinances unless necessary: These can reset your LTV clock and undo any progress made on PMI removal.
• Leverage windfalls strategically: Any financial boost (bonus, tax return, inheritance) is a great opportunity for principal reduction that may tip the scale for removal.

FHA-to-Conventional Refinance: Special Case PMI Removal

• Monitor your credit score: Qualify for conventional financing by staying within the right credit band.
• Monitor local market trends and assess current valuations through agents, online tools, or a pre-listing appraisal.
• Apply for a new loan when refinance fees make sense compared to remaining FHA MIP payments.
• Aim for an LTV of 80% or lower for no-PMI qualification.

Quick PMI Savings and Removal Checklist

• Check your loan type and confirm whether PMI or MIP applies.
• Review your loan documents for the date and LTV when PMI is scheduled to drop.
• Calculate your current LTV at every major payment or home value milestone.
• Get quotes from multiple lenders before closing to compare initial PMI.
• Budget for appraisals if planning to request PMI removal early.
• Schedule yearly check-ins on your progress toward 80% LTV.
• Make extra principal payments when feasible.
• Keep payment records clean; avoid late or missed payments.
• Please consult with your lender or servicer for their specific instructions on removing PMI.
• Evaluate refinancing if your rate, equity, or value has improved dramatically.

Conclusion: Private Mortgage Insurance

Paying PMI can feel like throwing money away, but it’s not a one-time cost if you plan your paydown properly, shop for your initial mortgage wisely, and keep a close eye on market values and equity. By understanding all the routes to lowering and removing PMI, US homeowners can knock years off their insurance payments and redirect that monthly expense toward building real wealth at home.

Whether you’re just buying with less than 20% down or already deep into your mortgage, aggressive principal reduction, a proactive removal request, or a well-timed refinance can make a huge financial difference.

The buyer who checks their statements, plans for value growth, and stays organized is the one who wins the PMI game. Leverage the tips above, talk with lenders often, and set reminders for LTV milestones—you’ll not only save monthly, but start realizing the true financial benefits of homeownership far sooner. That’s how you make the US housing system work smarter for you.

Beem simplifies money management, making it easier to stay on top of your finances. From saving for a home to improving everyday budgeting, Beem provides tools and guidance at every step.