Appeals Process: Overturn Denials with Supporting Evidence

Health insurance claim denials are more common than most people realize, and they can occur for a variety of reasons, ranging from simple coding errors to more complex issues, such as coverage limits or missing documentation. For patients and families already navigating medical challenges, a denial notice can feel overwhelming and frustrating. However, most claim denials are not final. With the right approach, strong supporting evidence, and a methodical process, many denials can be successfully appealed.

Appealing a denial ensures that patients receive the coverage they are entitled to and prevents unnecessary financial strain. By taking proactive steps, you can often overturn a denial and secure the payment or coverage approval that should have been granted initially. Tools such as Beem make the process more manageable by helping people organize documents, track submission deadlines, and understand the appeals process with greater efficiency. In this blog, we delve into the entire appeals process.

Appeals Process: Types of Claim Denials

Understanding why claims are denied is the first step in knowing how to respond effectively. Denials are not always final, and most of them occur due to issues that can be corrected through an appeal.

Common Reasons for Denials

Insurance denials occur for various reasons, many of which can be corrected through a careful review and proper documentation. Some of the most common include:

• Non-covered services or procedures – If a treatment falls outside the insurer’s coverage policies, the claim may be denied. Sometimes, this occurs due to a misunderstanding of medical necessity.
• Missing or incorrect documentation – Claims often require detailed records, test results, and accurate coding. If something is missing or entered incorrectly, denial is likely.
• Exceeding coverage limits – Many plans have limits on the number of visits, therapies, or services. Once those are reached, additional claims may be denied.
• Pre-authorization not obtained – Some procedures require pre-approval before they are performed. Without it, coverage may be denied even if the treatment was medically necessary.

Denial Codes and Explanation

When a claim is denied, insurers typically provide an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) or a denial letter. These documents include denial codes, which explain the specific reason behind the decision. Understanding these codes is crucial, as they guide the type of appeal you should file and the evidence you need to present.

Tip: Platforms like Beem can help interpret denial codes and break down the next steps in a way that makes the appeals process easier to follow.

Step-by-Step Appeals Process

The appeals process can feel intimidating, but breaking it into clear steps makes it more manageable. Each step builds on the previous one, ensuring you provide complete documentation and meet every required deadline.

Step 1 – Review the Denial Letter

The first step is carefully reviewing the denial notice you receive from your insurer. Pay close attention to the explanation provided and the type of appeal permitted. Some denials allow for an internal appeal within the insurer, while others may eventually escalate to an external review. The letter will also include critical deadlines, and missing these deadlines can forfeit your right to appeal.

Step 2 – Gather Supporting Evidence

Evidence is the foundation of any successful appeal. The stronger your documentation, the higher your chance of overturning the denial. Common pieces of evidence include:

• Medical records such as progress notes, test results, and imaging reports
• Letters from physicians explaining why the treatment was medically necessary
• Copies of bills, prior approvals, and correspondence with the insurer

Tip: Beem provides tools to organize all necessary documents in one place, making it easier to submit a complete and convincing appeal package.

Step 3 – Write a Clear Appeal Letter

Your appeal letter is the formal communication that ties everything together. It should include:

• Claim number and patient information
• A concise explanation of why you believe the denial was incorrect
• Reference to the supporting evidence you have attached
• A clear request for resolution, such as approval of coverage or payment of the claim

Writing in a straightforward, professional manner helps reviewers focus on the facts and the strength of your evidence.

Step 4 – Submit the Appeal

Insurers have specific requirements for submitting appeals. These may include mailing hard copies, uploading documents to an online portal, or sending materials by email. Always follow these instructions exactly and keep copies of everything you submit for your own records.

Step 5 – Follow Up

After submission, it is important to track the progress of your appeal. Insurers may request additional documentation or clarification to verify the information provided. Staying on top of deadlines and maintaining open communication ensures that your appeal continues to move forward without unnecessary delays.

Tips to Strengthen Your Appeal

Strengthening your appeal requires more than just providing documents. It involves presenting your case in a way that is professional, clear, and supported by both evidence and insurer policy language, thereby increasing your chances of a successful outcome.

• Be concise and organized – Long, unfocused appeals are less effective than those that present evidence clearly.
• Include all relevant documentation – Attach medical records, necessity letters, and billing details to back your case.
• Reference policy language – If the insurer’s policy supports your case, quote or reference it directly.
• Keep a timeline of events – Document when claims were submitted, when denials were received, and when appeals were filed.
• Utilize technology for tracking – With Beem’s platform, you can manage submissions, deadlines, and communications within a single, streamlined workflow.

When to Escalate Your Appeal

Not every appeal will succeed the first time. Knowing when and how to escalate ensures you continue pursuing coverage through higher levels of review while meeting your rights as a policyholder.

• Second-level internal appeal – If your initial appeal is denied, many insurers allow you to request an additional internal review to reassess the claim thoroughly.
• External review – If internal appeals fail, you can request an independent review through an external organization. These reviews are impartial and binding on insurers.
• State-level escalation – State insurance boards also oversee disputes and may intervene, especially if consumer protections are in place.

Beem can help guide you through the escalation process, identifying the right next step, and providing reminders about submission requirements and deadlines.

How Beem Helps You Overturn Denials

Appealing denied claims is easier with the right tools and support. Beem offers a structured approach that helps individuals handle every stage of the process, from gathering evidence to tracking insurer responses and deadlines.

• Workflow tracking – Easily manage denied claims, important deadlines, and active appeals from one centralized dashboard, keeping the entire appeals process organized and accessible.
• Supporting tools – Collect, store, and organize essential documents like medical records, physician letters, bills, and correspondence to create a strong, well-documented appeal package.
• Templates and guidance – Use structured templates and detailed resources designed to help you draft professional, persuasive appeal letters that highlight evidence and medical necessity.
• Deadline reminders – Receive timely notifications about submission dates and follow-ups, ensuring you never miss critical deadlines and your appeal stays on track.

Conclusion

A claim denial can feel like a setback, but it isn’t the end of the process. By carefully reviewing the denial, gathering compelling evidence, writing a clear appeal letter, and staying on top of deadlines, you significantly increase your chances of having the decision overturned. If necessary, escalation options such as second-level appeals, external reviews, or state-level oversight provide additional avenues for securing coverage.

Using Beem’s platform streamlines the process by helping you track claims, organize medical records, and meet deadlines efficiently. With the right combination of preparation, persistence, and smart tools, you can navigate the appeals process successfully and secure the coverage you deserve. Download the app here.

FAQs for Appeals Process: Overturn Denials with Supporting Evidence