Why Withdrawing Retirement Funds Early Is Costly

Tapping into your retirement savings early can be very tempting. An unforeseen expense may come up, or it may just feel like you have to buy a new car right now. The downside is that, while it may help for now, dipping into your retirement accounts will still significantly affect your financial future.

If you look at it from the perspective of 401(k)s, IRAs, or Roth IRAs, the accounts are meant to help you get financially secure in your old age. They do that by relying on long-term growth and compounding to accumulate a large enough sum that will last throughout retirement. Having funds available before the age of retirement you have set means you are disrupting this growth, which often results in a significant reduction in your retirement savings.

To some, withdrawing money early from their accounts may seem like a minor issue, but this is far from the truth. Such transactions may result in approved penalties, tax liabilities, and the loss of the opportunity to earn interest through compounding. Adding up these factors will not only affect your financial security but also your ability to retire in comfort.

In the following blog, we will discuss the reasons why it is a costly mistake to withdraw funds from retirement accounts early, the financial repercussions you would face, existing exceptions, ways to avoid early withdrawals, and the impact on your lifestyle in the long run.

The Financial Consequences of Early Retirement Withdrawals

1. Early Withdrawal Penalties from Retirement Accounts

If you are not very good with financial planning overall, you might often look at your retirement corpus every time there is an urgent need for money. If you are in your 20s or 30s, retirement or superannuation seems far away, and you often think there is nothing wrong with withdrawing something out of your own money. However, with the YOLO (You Only Live Once) mentality, it is easy to ignore the early withdrawal penalties from retirement accounts that not only reduce your corpus but also negatively impact your future earnings. 

Most retirement accounts, including 401(k)s and traditional IRAs, impose a 10% penalty on early withdrawals made before age 59 ½. This is designed to discourage people from tapping into retirement funds before they reach retirement age.

Let us assume that if you withdraw $10000 from your 401(k) early and it can result in an additional $1000 in penalties besides your regular income taxes. This implies that your corpus is reduced by $1000, which could have a serious impact on the compounding rate and the future retirement fund. 

You might argue the relevance of these penalties, but the purpose is to protect your long-term financial security more than anything else. They are significant because they create an immediate loss, reducing both your available funds now and the potential growth those funds could generate in the future.

2. Paying Taxes on Withdrawn Funds

When you withdraw some amount from your retirement fund, such early withdrawals are also subject to regular income taxes. These retirement contributions are typically made out of pre-tax income and hence the taxes are deferred until withdrawals are made. However, once you withdraw early, the money is taxable income for the year in which such amount is received. 

Example: If you withdraw $10,000 from a 401(k) and your marginal tax rate is 20%, you will owe $2,000 in taxes, reducing your take-home amount to $8,000. When combined with the 10% penalty, your effective loss could be $3,000, or 30% of the original withdrawal. Hence, you should understand the importance of having different sources of savings and investments rather than relying on your retirement funds for such emergency withdrawals. 

3. The Missed Opportunity for Compound Growth

As has been mentioned over a couple of instances in this blog earlier, while withdrawing anything from your retirement fund, you tend to ignore the importance and opportunity for compound growth. However, we must inform you that you are not alone in not recognizing the importance of compounding. It is a quite effective but highly underrated aspect of financial management. 

Compounding or timely appreciation of money takes months and years to take effect, but when it does, it helps your money grow exponentially. People often cite the example of how Warren Buffett’s wealth multiplied only after he turned 60. The important thing here to notice is that you must keep your fund intact, do not withdraw unnecessarily and let compounding take its course. 

Example: Imagine a 30-year-old withdraws $5,000 from their retirement account. Assuming an average annual return of 7%, $5,000 could have grown to over $27,000 by age 65. By withdrawing early, not only do you lose the principal, but also decades of potential growth.

Hence, the results are quite relevant: the earlier you withdraw, the greater the impact on your future retirement balance. Even small withdrawals today can translate into significant losses over decades due to compounding.

Why Early Withdrawals Harm Long-Term Financial Goals

1. Slower Growth of Retirement Savings

The importance of compounding has been elaborated on a couple of instances, and taking money out of retirement disrupts the long-term growth of the savings. Any amount withdrawn earlier no longer contributes to your future retirement fund. 

Example: Withdrawing $5,000 from a 401(k) at age 35 might reduce retirement savings by tens of thousands of dollars by age 65. That money could have continued compounding year after year, providing a much larger nest egg.

Retirement accounts do not comprise multibagger stocks or risky investments. They are designed in a way that they could grow over decades. When you remove funds prematurely, it slows down the entire process and accumulation of wealth is no longer possible. 

2. Longer Timeframe to Save for Retirement

Early withdrawals create a gap in your retirement savings. To compensate, you may need to save more aggressively or work longer to reach your financial goals. This can impact your current financial conditions. You can use the step-up technique, whereby you can increase the contribution slightly each month or year, thereby ensuring that the retirement planning is well on track. 

3. Increased Risk of Running Out of Money in Retirement

With increased life expectancy or unexpected future expenses, having a low retirement fund can easily result in an increased risk of running out of money during retirement. This is the time when you do not have any active employment or income sources. 

Example: A $100,000 retirement fund could lose a substantial portion of its projected future value if early withdrawals are made repeatedly. The snowball effect of these losses can significantly impact your lifestyle during retirement.

What Are the Exceptions to Early Withdrawal Penalties?

Although early withdrawals are generally costly, there are specific exceptions where penalties may not apply. Understanding these rules can save you from unnecessary financial loss.

1. Qualified Exceptions for Early IRA Withdrawals

The IRS allows penalty-free early withdrawals from IRAs for certain purposes:

• Qualified higher education expenses
  
• Medical costs exceeding a percentage of your adjusted gross income
  
• First-time home purchase (up to $10,000)
  

Solution: Familiarize yourself with these exceptions before making withdrawals to avoid penalties whenever possible. Consider using Beem to spend, save, plan and protect your hard-earned money like an pro with effective financial insights and suggestions.

2. 401(k) Withdrawals Under Specific Circumstances

Some circumstances permit penalty-free 401(k) withdrawals, such as:

• Permanent disability
  
• Certain medical expenses
  
• Substantial financial hardship, as defined by your plan
  

Solution: Consult your plan administrator to determine whether your situation qualifies for a penalty-free withdrawal. Even if penalties are waived, taxes may still apply.

3. Roth IRA Contributions vs. Earnings

With a Roth IRA, you can withdraw contributions at any time without penalties, because these were made with after-tax dollars. However, earnings on those contributions are subject to penalties if withdrawn before age 59 ½, except under certain exceptions.

Solution: Understand the distinction between contributions and earnings. Planning withdrawals from Roth IRAs requires careful consideration to avoid unnecessary penalties.

Strategies for Avoiding Early Retirement Fund Withdrawals

1. Build an Emergency Fund

An emergency fund acts as a financial buffer, reducing the need to dip into retirement savings for unexpected costs.

Solution: Save 3–6 months’ worth of living expenses in a liquid account that’s easily accessible. This fund can cover medical emergencies, job loss, or urgent home repairs without jeopardizing retirement funds.

2. Explore Alternative Sources of Income

Instead of tapping into retirement accounts, consider short-term solutions:

• Part-time work or side hustles
  
• Selling unused assets
  
• Borrowing from non-retirement savings
  

Solution: These alternatives address immediate financial needs without compromising your long-term retirement security.

3. Borrow Against Your Retirement Funds (With Caution)

Some 401(k) plans allow participants to borrow from their account rather than withdraw.

Solution: Borrowing can be safer than early withdrawals because it avoids penalties and preserves long-term growth. However, only borrow if you can repay according to plan rules; failure to repay converts the loan into a taxable withdrawal.

4. Take Advantage of Tax-Advantaged Accounts

Certain tax-advantaged accounts, like Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) or Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs), allow you to pay for qualified medical expenses without penalties.

Solution: Utilize these accounts for healthcare costs, which can prevent unnecessary withdrawals from retirement funds.

The Long-Term Cost of Early Withdrawals on Retirement Security

1. Impact on Your Retirement Lifestyle

Early withdrawals reduce your retirement savings, which may force you to adjust your expected standard of living.

Example: A 25-year-old who withdraws funds early may need to save significantly more over the next 40 years to maintain a comfortable retirement by age 65. Every early withdrawal creates a gap that is difficult to fill.

2. The Snowball Effect of Losing Growth Potential

Compounding works best when money is left untouched. Early withdrawals decrease the potential for exponential growth.

Solution: Keep your retirement savings intact to maximize the effect of compounding. Avoid withdrawals unless under true emergency or qualifying exception.

3. The Risk of Post-Retirement Financial Stress

Reducing retirement savings early can result in financial stress later in life. Insufficient funds may require you to work longer, delay retirement, or reduce your lifestyle.

Solution: Protect your retirement security by adhering to disciplined savings strategies and resisting the temptation to withdraw early.

Conclusion: The Costs of Withdrawing Retirement Funds Early Are High

It is not easy, of course, to wait to retire before you take out money from your retirement savings, but on the other hand, you will face major repercussions if you do so. Withdrawals that are made before the retirement age obscure the long-term financial security with their penalties, taxes, and losses due to lack of compound growth.

To make your future financially stable, you should first:

• Set up a reserve to cover emergencies so that you will not need to take money from your retirement account
• Check out different sources of income
• If necessary, take loans, but very carefully
• Make use of tax-advantaged accounts for certain expenses

When you keep your retirement account untouched and let it grow, you create not only a more secure financial future but also a comfortable and stress-free retirement. Use Beem to get beneficial insights on where to cut costs, where to spend and how to save your money with your personalized Budget Planner.

Download the Beem app here.

FAQs on Why Withdrawing Retirement Funds Early Is Costly