Table of Contents
A Smarter Way to Insure Seasonal Vehicles?
Not all vehicles are driven year-round. Classic cars, motorcycles, RVs, and convertibles often spend months in storage, making full insurance coverage during off-seasons feel unnecessary. To cut costs, many owners consider comprehensive-only coverage, which removes liability and collision protection but retains coverage for non-driving risks like theft or weather damage.
While the savings can be substantial, this strategy also comes with potential risks—especially if the vehicle is unexpectedly used. Tools like Beem simplify the process by comparing insurance options side by side, helping you decide whether comprehensive-only coverage is right for your seasonal vehicle.
What Is Comprehensive-Only Coverage?
Comprehensive-only coverage is a type of car insurance designed to protect stored or rarely driven vehicles. It covers damage not caused by driving but rather by external events.
What It Covers:
- Theft
- Fire
- Vandalism
- Weather damage (hail, flooding)
- Falling objects
- Animal-related damage (e.g., rodents chewing wires)
For example, comprehensive insurance would pay for the repairs if a tree branch falls on your RV during winter storage. Similarly, you’d be protected if your classic car is vandalized in a garage or a raccoon causes electrical damage.
What It Doesn’t Cover:
- Liability coverage (damage you cause to others)
- Collision coverage (damage from accidents while driving)
This means the vehicle is protected while stored, but not if it’s driven—even for a short distance.
Who Uses It?
Comprehensive-only coverage is popular for:
- Long-term storage vehicles
- Low-mileage secondary vehicles
- Seasonal-use vehicles (e.g., summer convertibles or campers)
Maintaining this limited coverage also helps avoid a lapse in insurance history, which can lead to higher premiums when full coverage is reinstated.
Read related blog: Car Insurance for Seasonal and Part-Time Drivers
Vehicles That Often Get Comprehensive-Only Coverage
Certain vehicles are more suited for seasonal coverage due to their usage patterns.
Classic Cars in Winter Storage
Collectors often store classic cars during colder months to avoid snow, salt, and rust. Comprehensive-only protections against storage-related risks without paying for unneeded road coverage.
Convertibles in the Off-Season
A convertible might be ideal for summer, but it’s likely parked during winter. Reducing liability and collision during those idle months saves money while protecting the car.
RVs, Campers, and Motorcycles
Recreational vehicles and motorcycles often sit unused during colder seasons. Comprehensive-only insurance ensures they remain covered without high premiums for unused liability coverage.
Rarely Driven Secondary Vehicles
Backup cars or third vehicles that are seldom driven may be ideal candidates. Full insurance may be more expensive than necessary if a car is parked most of the year.
Pros of Choosing Comprehensive-Only
Significant Cost Savings
Liability and collision coverage often comprise most of an auto policy’s premium. Dropping them can save hundreds of dollars annually.
Protection Against Storage Risks
Even a parked car is vulnerable to damage. Comprehensive-only ensures coverage against theft, fire, vandalism, and natural disasters while the vehicle is off the road.
Maintains Continuous Insurance History
Canceling insurance altogether can create a coverage gap. That gap can result in higher premiums when you reinstate full coverage. Comprehensive-only keeps your insurance history active.
Read related blog: Insurance for Electric Vehicles: What’s Different in 2025?
Risks of Comprehensive-Only Coverage
No Liability Coverage If You Drive
Even a short drive without liability insurance puts you at major financial risk. If you cause an accident, you’ll be personally responsible for damages—potentially tens of thousands of dollars.
Driving Without Liability Is Illegal
In most states, operating a vehicle on public roads without liability coverage is against the law. Penalties can include fines, license suspension, or even vehicle impoundment.
No Coverage for Moving Damage
Moving the vehicle around—even in your driveway—and causing damage may not be covered. Without collision coverage, you’d pay out of pocket for repairs.
Lenders May Prohibit It
Your lender may require full coverage if the vehicle is leased or financed. Dropping liability or collision coverage could breach your loan terms and lead to forced insurance or penalties.
Cost Comparison – Full Coverage vs Comprehensive-Only
The potential for savings is significant, particularly when the vehicle will be in storage for several months.
- Full Coverage: ~$1,200/year
- Comprehensive-Only: ~$250/year
- Annual Savings: ~$950+
For households with multiple seasonal vehicles, the savings can quickly multiply. However, this must be weighed against the potential cost of an uninsured accident.
One short drive without liability coverage could cost more than a year’s savings.
Read related blog: Windshield Claims: Repair vs Replacement and Deductible Choices
Smart Ways to Use Comprehensive-Only Coverage
To maximize benefits and avoid pitfalls, consider the following best practices:
Use Only for Vehicles That Will Not Be Driven
Keep liability active if there’s even a slight chance you’ll drive the vehicle. Otherwise, the financial and legal risk is too high.
Look into Seasonal or Lay-Up Insurance
Some insurers offer policies specifically for vehicles in storage, suspending certain coverage types while maintaining protection.
Notify Your Insurer Before Making Changes
Always contact your insurance company when switching to or from comprehensive-only. This ensures correct documentation and prevents coverage gaps.
Reinstate Full Coverage Before Driving Again
Before taking the car out of storage, ensure liability (and if needed, collision) coverage is active. Driving without it can be both dangerous and illegal.
Read related blog: Cheapest Full Coverage Car Insurance
Alternatives to Comprehensive-Only
Consider other money-saving options for seasonal or infrequently used vehicles, depending on your needs.
Storage or Lay-Up Policies
These are tailored for parked vehicles and may offer broader protection. They function similarly to comprehensive-only but are specifically built for seasonal use.
Usage-Based or Pay-Per-Mile Insurance
If you occasionally drive your vehicle, usage-based insurance may be smarter. Premiums are based on actual miles driven rather than flat rates.
Multi-Vehicle Discounts
If you insure multiple cars under one policy, keeping full coverage on a seasonal car might still be affordable due to bundled discounts. Comparing options can help you decide.
Read related blog: First-Time Car Buyer? Car Insurance Tips No One Tells You
How Beem Helps With Seasonal Vehicle Insurance
Choosing the right insurance for your seasonal vehicle can feel complex. Beem simplifies the process by helping you compare policies in one place.
Why Use Beem?
- Compare comprehensive-only vs. full coverage options side by side.
- Identify insurers offering seasonal or lay-up policies.
- Evaluate cost, coverage limits, and insurer flexibility before deciding.
Use Beem to compare seasonal car insurance options today.
FAQs – Comprehensive-Only for Seasonal Vehicles
Is it legal to carry only comprehensive insurance?
Yes, but only if the vehicle is not driven. Operating a car without liability insurance is illegal in most states.
Can I drop liability if I’m still financing the vehicle?
Usually not. Most lenders require full coverage until the loan is paid off. Always check with your lender before making changes.
Can I switch back to full coverage anytime?
Yes. Contact your insurer to reinstate liability and collision coverage before driving again.
Does comprehensive insurance cover weather or rodent damage?
Yes. It typically includes hail, flood, falling objects, fire, vandalism, and animal damage (like rodents chewing wires).
Is comprehensive-only the same as storage insurance?
Not exactly. Storage (or lay-up) policies may include similar protections but are often more tailored for long-term parked vehicles.
Conclusion – A Smart Seasonal Move or a Costly Gamble?
Comprehensive-only coverage can be a smart, cost-saving solution for vehicles genuinely in storage. It protects against theft, weather, and other non-driving risks—while significantly lowering insurance costs.
However, it’s a risky move if the vehicle is driven, even once, without reinstating liability coverage. One mistake can result in massive out-of-pocket expenses and legal consequences.
With tools like Beem, you can confidently compare seasonal insurance options and make an informed decision that balances cost savings with the protection your vehicle needs. Download the app now!
