Table of Contents
When shopping for a new car, one of the first decisions you’ll face is whether to buy or lease—buying vs. leasing a car is a common dilemma for many consumers. Both options have advantages, but one crucial factor underpins both choices: your credit score. So, what role does credit play? It can significantly impact your eligibility, interest rates, and the terms offered, whether you’re financing a purchase or signing a lease agreement.
Whether you’re securing an auto loan or entering a lease agreement, your credit history affects not only your chances of approval but also your total cost, interest rates, upfront payments, and long-term financial commitment. Understanding how your credit plays into each option can help you make a more informed and financially sound decision.
This article breaks down the key differences between buying and leasing a car, how your credit score impacts both options, and how to determine which is better for your credit profile.
What’s the Difference Between Buying and Leasing a Car?
Before evaluating how credit factors into the process, it’s essential to understand the basic mechanics of buying and leasing a car.
Buying a Car
You become the vehicle owner when you buy a car—either with cash or through an auto loan. If you’re financing the purchase, you make monthly payments, including principal and interest, until the loan is paid off. At the end of the loan term, you own the car free and clear.
Key characteristics:
- Higher monthly payments (compared to leasing)
- Full ownership after loan term
- Unlimited mileage
- Ability to modify or sell the car anytime
- Responsible for all maintenance and repair costs after the warranty expires
Leasing a Car
Leasing a car is like renting it for a fixed term—typically between 24 and 48 months. You make monthly payments to use the vehicle but don’t own it. At the end of the lease term, you return the car or buy it at a predetermined price.
Key characteristics:
- Lower monthly payments
- Mileage restrictions (usually 10,000 to 15,000 miles annually)
- Need to return vehicle in good condition
- May incur penalties for wear and tear or exceeding mileage
- No ownership unless you choose to buy the car at lease end
Read related blog: Best Tips for Buying Car Insurance | Beem
How Credit Score Impacts Car Buying
When buying a car with financing, lenders use your credit score to determine whether to approve your loan and at what interest rate. Here’s how your credit profile influences the loan process.
Loan Approval
Lenders use your credit report and score to evaluate how risky it is to lend to you. You may be denied an auto loan or need a co-signer if your credit score is low. You’re more likely to be approved with fewer conditions if your score is high.
Interest Rates
One of the most significant impacts on your credit score is the interest rate you receive. This rate affects your monthly payment and the total amount you repay over time.
- Scores above 750 may qualify for interest rates below 5%
- Scores between 670–739 might result in 6–9% APR
- Scores below 600 often receive rates over 15%, or worse, maybe denied entirely
Even a 2–3% difference in interest rate can translate to thousands of dollars in savings over the loan term.
Down Payment Requirements
Lenders may require a larger down payment from borrowers with lower credit scores. A larger upfront payment reduces the loan amount and reassures the lender that you’re invested in the purchase.
Loan Term Flexibility
Higher credit scores give you more favorable loan terms, including longer durations and lower interest rates. This can help you reduce your monthly payments or minimize total interest costs.
How Credit Score Affects Leasing a Car
Leasing companies are often even stricter than auto loan lenders when evaluating creditworthiness. Since they retain ownership of the vehicle, they want assurance that the lessee will maintain the car and make timely payments.
Higher Credit Requirements
While you can often finance a car with fair or even poor credit, leasing typically requires a score of at least 680 or higher. Many lease deals are only available to individuals with scores above 700 or even 740.
People with lower scores may be denied a lease or offered a less favorable deal with higher upfront costs.
Security Deposits and Advance Payments
If you have average or fair credit, the leasing company may require a significant security deposit or multiple monthly payments upfront. These added costs can make leasing less appealing for people with borderline credit profiles.
Influence on Lease Terms
Your credit score can affect more than just approval—it may impact:
- The money factor (leasing’s version of interest rate)
- The residual value the leasing company estimates for the car
- Mileage limits or early termination penalties
Read related blog: How to Improve Your Credit Score Without a Credit Card
Buying vs. Leasing: Credit Score Comparison
Here’s a quick comparison of how credit score impacts each option:
| Credit Score | Range | Buying a Car | Leasing a Car |
| 300–579 | Poor | Likely denied or very high interest rates | Almost always denied |
| 580–669 | Fair | High interest rates, may need co-signer | Approval unlikely, enormous upfront costs if approved |
| 670–739 | Good | Moderate interest rates, good loan options | Possible approval, mid-range lease offers |
| 740–799 | Very Good | Low rates and flexible terms | Strong approval odds, low money factors |
| 800–850 | Excellent | Best rates and longest term options | Easiest lease approval, best terms and offers |
Additional Credit-Related Costs and Considerations
Aside from loan approval and interest rates, your credit score can influence other car-related costs and requirements.
Insurance Premiums
In many states, auto insurance companies use credit-based insurance scores to determine rates. Poor credit may increase your monthly premium by hundreds of dollars annually.
Origination and Acquisition Fees
Whether buying or leasing, your credit may impact fees:
- Loan origination fees may be higher with low credit
- Leasing acquisition fees may increase for subprime borrowers
Prepayment Penalties
Lenders may include clauses for early payment penalties if they deem the borrower to be a higher risk. Reading the fine print and asking questions is essential.
Leasing Penalties
Lessees with poor credit may receive less favorable residual value estimates or tighter mileage restrictions, raising the total cost if you exceed the lease agreement terms.
Should You Buy or Lease Based on Your Credit Score?
Your credit score doesn’t just affect your ability to finance or lease a car—it should help you decide which option is right for your situation.
If You Have Good or Excellent Credit
You can choose either option. Leasing may be attractive for lower monthly payments, driving newer vehicles more frequently, and avoiding long-term maintenance issues. Buying is better if you plan to keep the car for a long time and want to build equity.
If You Have Fair or Poor Credit
You can choose either option. Leasing may be attractive because it allows you to make lower monthly payments, drive newer vehicles more frequently, and avoid long-term maintenance issues. Buying is better if you plan to keep the car for a long time and want to build equity.
Read related blog: Does Car Leasing Include Insurance
Tips to Improve Your Credit Before Financing or Leasing
Improving your credit even slightly before applying can mean the difference between approval and rejection—or thousands of dollars in interest savings.
Pay Down Existing Debt
Reducing your credit card balances can significantly lower your credit utilization ratio, one of the key factors in your credit score.
Make Timely Payments
Your payment history makes up about 35% of your credit score. Ensure that all bills—credit cards, loans, utilities—are paid on time consistently.
Check and Dispute Credit Report Errors
Use free annual credit reports to identify errors or outdated information that may hurt your score. Dispute anything inaccurate through the major credit bureaus.
Avoid Opening New Accounts
Multiple credit inquiries in a short period can negatively impact your score. Avoid applying for new credit cards or loans in the months before applying for an auto loan or lease.
Keep Older Accounts Open
Older accounts help improve your credit age, boosting your overall score. Don’t close older cards because they’re unused unless they have annual fees.
How Beem Helps You Prepare for Auto Financing
Beem is an all-in-one financial tool that empowers users to track, manage, and improve their credit profiles in real-time. This gives them a better chance at securing favorable loan or lease terms.
Real-Time Credit Monitoring
Beem’s credit monitoring tool provides up-to-date credit score data so you can determine your standing before approaching lenders or dealerships.
Score Alerts and Payment Reminders
You receive personalized alerts when your score changes or a payment is due—reducing the risk of missed deadlines that can damage your credit.
Customized Credit-Building Insights
Beem offers personalized suggestions based on your unique credit profile, such as paying off a certain card or disputing a specific item on your report.
Loan and Lease Offer Comparisons
With Beem, you can preview real offers from trusted lenders based on your current credit score and financial standing. Apps like Beem ensure you’re not applying blindly and risking unnecessary credit checks or poor loan terms.
Read related blog: Stay on Track with Regular Credit Monitoring: How It Helps Protect Your Score
Frequently Asked Questions About Buying vs. Leasing a Car
What credit score is needed to lease a car?
Most leasing companies require a minimum score of 680. Scores above 740 usually qualify for the best lease deals and lowest money factors.
Can I lease a car with poor credit?
It isn’t easy. You may be asked to make multiple payments upfront or provide a hefty security deposit if approved. Buying is usually a better path for those with poor credit.
Is buying a car with poor credit a better option?
Yes. You may face high interest rates, but you’ll build ownership, and specific lenders or credit unions may be willing to work with you.
Will applying for an auto loan affect my credit?
Yes. Auto loan applications involve a hard credit inquiry, which may temporarily temporarily lower your score by a few points. However, multiple applications within a short time (14–45 days) are often grouped by credit scoring models.
How can I improve my credit before applying?
Focus on paying bills on time, lowering credit balances, checking your report for errors, and holding off on new applications. A credit monitoring tool like Beem can guide you through the process efficiently.
Final Thoughts
Buying and leasing both offer paths to driving your next vehicle—but your credit score plays a pivotal role in shaping either option’s cost, terms, and viability.
If your credit is strong, you’ll likely be eligible for attractive offers whether you lease or buy. If your credit is less-than-perfect, buying may be your best bet—with options to rebuild your score.
No matter where you stand, the key is preparation. Before stepping into a dealership, use a trusted platform like Beem to monitor your credit, understand your options, and take control of your financial journey. Download the app now!
